Students in the 2004
seminar, "Geisha in History, Fiction and Fantasy" have taken the first
steps toward creating a comprehensive annotated bibliography of works in
English about geisha. Future geisha seminar students will expand
this list with annotations of still other books--those that specifically
refer to geisha and others that link to this topic by their focus on either
the sex industry or other representations of Japanese women.
A wide variety of depictions of the geisha emerge here--icon of a "secret"
floating world of sexual pleasure; refined, elegant artist; victim
of the cruel "mothers" and lecherous "patrons;" doll-like, subservient,young
beauty; clever, independent businesswoman; Edo-era spy; and even the comic
figure who can undo the allied powers in the occupied Japan (Teahouse
of the August Moon). It is especially interesting in reading
this list to note the re-publication of DeBecker's work on the Yoshiwara
pleasure quarters (1906, 1971, 2002), and to think about the different
cultural landscapes that shaped an audience for this book. One can also
consider the slightly different versions of Downer's book on geisha published
in Britain and the U.S. respectively, and the quite different covers on
each. Certainly, there is no straightforward path to tracing the
history, fiction and fantasy involving geisha.
Bennett, James Gordon. My Father’s
Geisha. New York: Delacorte Press, 1990.
This book is about a boy
growing up in a dysfunctional military family of a philandering father,
a suspicious mother, and a crazy sister suffering mentally and physically
from a thyroid problem. The father is always over seas on various
assignments, the mother is always conscious of her husband's one night
stands, and the family is constantly moving. The book is written
from the viewpoint of the boy who grows from adolescence to adulthood before
the reader. Although it is known throughout the book that the father
is continuously being unfaithful, it is not until the second to the last
chapter, entitled “My Father’s Geisha,” that we learn that the father has
any relations with a geisha. The word geisha is only used twice and
the reader is never given much of an image or idea of what a geisha truly
is. The geisha here is portrayed as a mistress figure that acts as
a housewife and companion after she and the father are married, and she
is Korean not Japanese. A reader seeking to learn about geisha from
this book would take away the idea that a geisha is an Asian mistress
and a potential wife who performs menial tasks. This depiction could
not be more different than Lesley Downer's or Liza Dalby's descriptions,
for example, of a geisha as a Japanese woman trained in traditional music
and other arts, who has mastered conversation and the entertainment of
men. If you are looking for a book that describes the lifestyle and
art of geisha, or anything at all about women who work as geisha, this
is not the book for you. The book does exemplify, however, the way
the term geisha is used in much English-language media to signifiy the
exotically erotic.--Keats Webb
Chandler, Billie T. The Geisha Story:
with doll-and-flower arrangements. Rutland: Tuttle Co.,
1963. 56 pages.
First and foremost, this
book showcases the author’s doll-and-flower arrangements. These arrangements
are a combination of tradition Japanese ikebana, or flower arrangements,
and the display of Hakata dolls, little porcelain dolls that are made to
look realistic. The book is obviously artistic, starting with the
blue and gold brocade cover. Having created several of these doll-and-flower
arrangements, the author has grouped different genres together and this
is a display of those containing geisha. Along with the pictures
of geisha, the author gives a brief history of the geisha. This history
includes the stories of some famous geisha such as O-kichi and O-koi.
It is also a good reference for getting some views on the origins of geisha.
Moreover, it is a good way to see how an American knowledgeable about geisha
tries to describe and explain geisha in a way that will make it easy for
other Americans to understand. At times, the author appears condescending,
using terms such as “most Westerners” and describing “our” misconceptions
about geisha, such as ideas that geisha are only prostitutes and don’t
have to learn anything artistic. The 12 full-color photographs of
the doll-and-flower arrangements at the back of the book are a good way
to get an idea of geisha in their “natural environment”, as the author
describes it. The dolls are highly detailed, so the photos could
even be used to view kimono and hairstyles. Lastly, these pictures
nicely portray traditional Japanese flower arrangement and the simple elegance
of Japanese beauty. --Charlotte Nunn
De Becker, J.E. The Sexual Life of
Japan. Private Printing: Japan, 1906.
The Sexual Life of Japan
was privately published in 1906 by J.E. De Becker. It is a review
of the history of the Yoshiwara Yukwaku pleasure quarters, which was a
prostitution district that evolved under the Tokugawa government of early
17th century Japan. The history is told like a narrative that is
interspersed with legal documents, medical statistics, copies of petitions,
and inventory lists of brothels. The author uses these forms of information
to keep the narrative completely fact-focused. In the preface, De
Becker clearly states that his intention as a historian is not to imply
any moral judgment on prostitution, and that he intends to obtain this
impartial tone by confining himself to assured facts. He addresses
the reader as if he or she has some knowledge of Japanese history, in that
he does not go into any detail about the formation or make-up of the Tokugawa
government. The book is divided up into around a hundred one to three
page segments, all listed in the table of contents under very specific
subjects, so specific topics are easy to find. The only confusing
part of the book can be the Japanese terms that De Becker uses; he does
not always give helpful definitions for them, and he tends to define a
word early in the book and reuse the same word far later without defining
it again. This can be confusing to the reader who is not familiar
with the Japanese language. One five page section describes the history,
fashion, hairstyles, and business patterns of the geisha. This section
is small but dense with detail, so it is helpful to one looking for information
on the intricacies of the Geisha practices and ceremonies, with little
emphasis on the ideologies they embody. De Becker presents them simply
as accomplished business-minded women, and does not mention any emotions
or problems that Geisha face.--Elizabeth Dale
De Becker, J.E. The Nightless City
or The History of the Yoshiwara Yukwaku. 5th ed. Rutland: Charles E.
Tuttle Company, 1971. 386 pages.
**A later publication
of the book annotated above.
De Becker succeeds
in his objective of explaining the history of the Yoshiwara. It is difficult
to read at times because of the lengthy paragraphs, and finding information
can be a challenge because the book is broken into over 100 sections. The
sections range from short paragraphs to twelve pages and the longer sections
are broken up by illustrations. Though related sections are placed near
each other, there is no logical transition from one topic to the next in
most cases. Overall, the information given is specific, and shows the reader
precise details. Not only does De Becker use Japanese terms when describing
things, but he also defines some Japanese phrases used in the Yoshiwara
to give readers a better idea of what was important in the Yoshiwara lifestyle.
For instance, “the piling up and exhibition of bedding” (108) has its own
distinct phrase and meaning behind it. Because the Yoshiwara was partially
built for prostitutes, geisha are mentioned several times throughout the
book. There is no section devoted simply to geisha; rather the book is
divided according to events surrounding their lives. If looking for a basic
definition of geisha, this is not the book to use, but it will be extremely
useful if one wants specific details on different aspects of the geisha
life. One also has to be careful not to confuse geisha with courtesan because
De Becker often quickly switches between terms, however by reading the
title of the section or the first few sentences, one can figure it out.
In general, the book is easy to read and De Becker shares his knowledge
in a friendly manner. --Jennifer Fair
De Becker, J.E. The Nightless City
of the Geisha. New York, NY. Kegan Paul Limited, 2002.
**Yet another
publication of this book
“The
author of this book was a lawyer and a long-time resident of Japan.” This
book gives an in-depth history of Japan’s Yoshiwara district. This book
is extremely entertaining as well as informative. Halfway through the book
the author includes an extensive list of Japanese charms and superstitions
relating to sneezing, toothaches, mind-reading, and attracting guests to
name a few. De Becker relates customs of the various houses in which women
worked and men frequented. He even shows us the symbols that were used
to represent the different classes of courtesans. The author relates common
experiences of the Yoshiwara geisha and the other classes of entertainers
also employed there. He highlights the legal relationships within the Yoshiwara;
for example, the included excerpts from legal documents and letters pertaining
to the creation of the Yoshiwara add validity to the book’s historical
content. The author gives an example of a document used when a girl was
sold by her family into a brothel. The reader of this book will have a
large amount of information regarding the technical aspects of the Yoshiwara,
but will less likely have an emotional response as personal stories are
infrequent. Although it would be hard to find specific information, as
the chapters in the book are in chronological order and not grouped by
content, this book would be a great primary source on the history of the
first “pleasure quarters” in Japan and, reading like a novel, is extremely
interesting.--Jeanne Walkowe
Downer, Lesley. The Secret History
of the Geisha: Women of the Pleasure Quarters. New York: Broadway Books,
2001.
The popularity of Arthur
Golden’s book Memoirs of a Geisha led to a heightened interest in
the geisha as an exotic symbol of Japanese culture. The Secret History
of the Geisha: Women of the Pleasure Quarters is perfect for readers
who are intrigued and fascinated by Japanese culture and the geisha. Lesley
Downer delved deep into the ‘secret’ world of the geisha and wrote this
extraordinary book that combines history with personal anecdotes and geisha
stories. Many historical and research-oriented books are tedious and difficult
to read, but Downer integrates all aspects of the geisha in a simple, yet
elegant fashion. She addresses the declining popularity of the geisha but
embraces what still remains. In order to obtain a majority of her information
she had to enter the geisha world which is often near impossible for a
Westerner. However, through patience she was slowly accepted into their
world. She had to buy the ‘correct’ rice cakes for the women she came in
contact with such as shamisen teachers and okiya mothers. Her stories are
fascinating and really give the reader a sense of what and who a geisha
is. In addition, Downer clearly and effectively explains the differences
between Japanese courtesan, maiko, geisha, and geiko. Overall, Lesley Downer
wrote an astonishing novel which is perfect for anyone with an interest
in the true geisha. --Kristin Mulgrew
Downer, Lesley. Geisha: The Secret
History of a Vanishing World. BPR Publishers, 2000.
**Basically the
same book as published in the U.S.; see annotation above.
This book presents geisha
as liberated women whom are freed from the confines of marriage, able to
pursue independent careers as artists and entertainers, as well as eventually
run their own businesses. Geisha are not presented as prostitutes but as
arts people. They perform arts like singing, dancing or playing a musical
instrument and are masters of the art of conversation. The “real secret
history” of the geisha is explored here through methods of interviews and
witnessing geisha’s everyday lives which most people do not experience.
Downer examines many aspects of the geisha world, both past and present.
She comments on rituals and lifestyles of historical geisha and compares
them to modern day contemporary geisha, who are not required to do such
rigorous training as their predecessors. There is plenty of information
covering the development of the geisha from their background, starting
as courtesans and artists. It goes through to their rise in popularity
in the 19th and 20th century as key figures in influencing politicians
and company chairmen. It also provides insight on their present declining
and redefining state. Lesley Downer also covers famous geisha and their
tales, the diverse geisha communities both the modern and traditional.
There are facts presented on their Japanese sexual attitudes, the role
of the wife to the geisha. Geisha history and lifestyle is described; more
specifically, there is statistics and information provided on male geisha,
Taikomochi, although very brief. Overall this book portrays geisha as feminists,
due to their liberated lifestyles, and provides a different perspective
on women in Japan.--Brenda Bell.
Fell, Alison. The Pillow Boy of the
Lady Onogoro. New York, San Diego, London: Harcourt Brace & Company,
1994. 247 pages.
This novel depicts a woman
named Onogoro in Japanese court during the Heian period, the 11th century.
She works as a poet and a concubine for general Motosuke. In this
story females are, in general, stuck within a lifestyle they have little
or no control over. Onogoro is only visited when the general has time and
on his terms only. The general is a married man whose wife has a child
in the story. She is expected to be fulfilled in the position of mistress,
yet she has no power in changing the relationship. She actually becomes
sick with grief at times because she feels so unsatisfied with the way
in which she is treated. She also cannot achieve orgasm on her own. Secretly,
she has a blind boy by the name of Oyo tell her erotic stories to “help”
her along, this further takes away from her own sexual powers as a woman.
Throughout the book Onogoro questions her relationship with the general
and becomes closer to Oyo. Near the end of the story, Onoguro starts to
realize that she is not in love with the general, but feels that she has
an obligation to him. She finds herself falling in love with Oyu and feels
torn. In the end, Onoguro must make a decision between duty and love. She
feels trapped as a woman in Japanese society. Onogoro and the poets that
she associates with share some of her resentment. Some of the women are
more bitter than others. Throughout the book, renowned poets in the story
speak of male inadequacies and of female position.
As a court lady, Onogoro
is adept in the art of poetry. She entertains the general, loves the general,
but gets little affection in return for this. Although this is the normal
role played by a court lady, it seems doubtful to me that in real life,
a lady would have expected nothing else from her married lover. I believe
that much of the sexual interludes and liaisons are to spark Western interest
of what we perceive to be the erotic and exotic East. The novelist
comes at this story with a feminist perspective and addresses the reader
in a mostly third person omniscient point of view. Sometimes the author
makes situations where we see Oyu’s perspective, or the insect on the wall,
etc. This novel portrays the sexual lifestyle of poet and mistress
as a glamorous, beautiful, intelligent, and heartbreaking lifestyle.--Jill
Bauman
Gallagher, John. Geisha: A Unique
World of Tradition, Elegance, and Art. New York; Chrysalis Books,
2003.
Gallagher’s Geisha’s
lavish full-color photographs are its main highlight; they intensify the
perspective offered on Geisha and correlate appropriately to the text.
The author chooses to focus his attention on the actual activities involved
in being a geisha: the training, costumes, makeup, geisha district, and
history. Each of the six chapters focuses on one of these themes, but little
attention is given to the geisha as a cultural archetype of Japanese or
Asian women. The closest one finds to this is the chapter entitled “Geisha
in the Modern World,” which describes how modern geisha attempt to maintain
their positions as cultural curators while simultaneously co-existing with
modern life. In particular, the photos from this chapter are interesting:
geisha on cell phones, geisha with Harry Potter masks, geisha drinking
Coke, etc. The tone the author takes is objective and to the point; he
reports accurately the research on the specific subjects related to geisha
and is concise in doing so. Despite the otherwise commercial feel of the
book, the author makes no pretense at hiding the risqué social position
of geisha and freely acknowledges the roles of both tayu during feudal
Japan and the self-styled “geisha” prostitutes after WWII. Geisha
also has the advantage of being published recently and has commentary from
the “Flower and Willow World” on the recent surge of interest in geisha
stemming from the popularity of Author Golden’s Memoirs of a Geisha.
Given its great visual appeal and easy style, this book would be of great
use to someone unfamiliar with the geisha tradition who wanted to increase
their knowledge without reading something too dense. --John Jackson
Golden, Arthur. Memoirs of
a Geisha. New York: Vintage Books, 1997. 428 pages.
Memoirs of a Geisha
is the story of Chiyo, a young, poor Japanese girl sold into the pleasure
quarters, whose beautiful blue-grey eyes allow her not only access to the
world of geisha, but also help her to become one of its most successful
members. The reader follows Chiyo as she is forced to leave her home
and impoverished family after being sold. Chiyo goes on to suffer
in a monstrous geisha household yet eventually transforms into the
beautiful and powerful geisha Sayuri. The reader may be surprised
to realize that the author of this insightful view of a young woman’s life
is actually male. Arthur Golden’s novel, while beautifully written
and rich with geisha tradition, depicts the life of a geisha with more
idealism than realism. Few events in Sayuri’s life would actually
happen to the average geisha; having one of Gion’s most successful geisha
as a big sister, being painted by a world famous artist, and especially
marrying the man she’s always loved. Memoirs gives the false
impression that Sayuri’s life is similar to that of most geisha.
Also, Golden, being an American, adds a bit of western romanticism to the
novel – the geisha looking for love, and the happy ending. The average
geisha would never allow herself to fall in love with a man, especially
a man that was not her patron. A geisha’s welfare depends on the
satisfaction of her patron. All of these aspects combined make Memoirs
more of a rags-to-riches Japanese Cinderella fairy tale, rather than an
accurate representation of geisha life.--Jennifer Adams
Honey, Maureen and Jean Lee Cole, eds.
Madame
Butterfly and A Japanese Nightingale: Two Orientalist Texts.
New Jersey: Rutgers University Press, 2002.
Madame Butterfly,
the John Luther Long novel (1899) reprinted in this volume, begins in much
the way the entire text will continue, expressing how little concern some
American men had for the women from whom they sought temporary comfort
and, in some cases, marriage in Meiji Japan. Long divides his novel
into many short chapters, in some ways using the short choppy structure
to illustrate how brief and stilted the relationship between Pinkerton
and Cho-Cho-San is. The novel glosses over the details of Pinkerton’s
leaving for America again and the birth of their son, leaping directly
into the last throes of Butterfly’s longing for Pinkerton’s return and
into her subsequent giving up of her son to a better life than she could
give him. Long is, in fact, spare on many of the details that would provide
a more complete picture of the domestic life Cho-Cho-San and Pinkerton
would have had; the readers are left unsure of how Butterfly came
to be so in awe of Pinkerton and his Western ways. As light entertainment,
Long’s story is moving and full of detail on the exotic geisha figure of
Butterfly and her subservient ways. As a piece of literature on the
relationships between Japanese women and the American men who loved and
left them, it provided a skeletal example but no real insight on the topic.--
Katie Hutton
Hwang, David Henry. M. Butterfly.
New York: New American Library, 1988.
M. Butterfly is a surprisingly
interesting play based on a true story of a French diplomat who was so
in love with the idea of the stereotypical Asian woman who was supposed
to be submissive, always putting her man before herself. Gallimard was
so enraptured and caught up in this fantasy that he had no idea that Song
Liling, his ideal woman, was not only a spy for the Chinese government,
but in fact a man in disguise.
This play is an amusing
outtake on how “blind” love can be as his fantasy enabled him to ignore
all the tell tale signs, never wondering why his mistress would never fully
undress, or why she went away during the “nine months she was pregnant”.
The play also mocks the typical Western view of the Asian woman, as exhibited
in the very popular Madame Butterfly. It reverses the tale of the
Western lover who takes advantage of the pure and utterly devoted love
of the meek woman, and leaves her desolate and heartbroken, mocking such
an antiquated and stereotypical belief.
--Charlotte Tate
Iwasaki, Mineko. Geisha, A Life.
: Pocket Books, 2002. 368 pages.
Geisha, A Life is
the autobiography of Mineko Iwasaki, a geisha from the Gion Kobu district
of Japan. Iwasaki was the primary informant for Arthur Golden’s Memoirs
of a Geisha. Tracing her chronologically ending at the end her career
as geisha, the author considers herself to be the first woman who was a
part of this three hundred year old Japanese tradition to come forward
and speak out about her experience. The depiction of “the flower and willow
world” is mostly positive, only criticizing the strict rules of the geisha
system as well as the competitiveness and pressure that is inherent within
the society. The book focuses on the aesthetic beauty of geisha, especially
Japanese dance and the arts, and barely alludes to the sexuality of a geisha.
The book is not academic and therefore is not written with the intention
of teaching the reader about the minutia of geisha nevertheless, a clear
understanding of the culture and traditions can be gained from reading
Iwasaki’s work. The most beneficial characteristic of the book is that
Mineko starts as a young girl and as she explains her experiences with
each step of the geisha system, the reader absorbs a comprehensive understanding
of the phases of a geisha’s career. For this reason, the book gives a good
overall understanding of the geisha world. Geisha, A Life, is enjoyable
and informative and an important book for those who want to know more about
the life of a geisha in Gion Kobu.
--Maile Mercer
Louis, Lisa. Butterflies of the Night:
Mama-sans, Geisha, Strippers, and the Japanese Men they Serve. New
York: Tengu Books, 1992. 208 pages.
In this book, Lisa Louis
takes a firsthand approach to discovering the truth behind the mizu shobai,
or the “water trade” of the Japanese
entertainment and sex industry,
so named for the way the customers flow in and out of the bars and teahouses
like water moving in a
river. Louis reveals the
often-overlooked aspects of the lives of many of the “butterflies of the
night,” by becoming a bar hostess in Japan and by interviewing various
women that keep this entertainment industry afloat. She divides the book
into eight chapters, each with a
different focus: job hunting,
high-end clubs, geisha life, sex for money and lower end clubs, customers,
whites in the industry, outsider bars in Japan, and gangster involvement
in the “water trade.” This book provides an interesting, personal, and
easy-to-read look into all aspects of the sex industry of Japan as opposed
to glossing over thegrittier side of the business as many books do. In
addressing the geisha, Louis gives an outsider’s view of the geisha life,
a brief history of the women, and the personal story of one geisha mama
who did not live the stereotypical geisha life. From this work it is clear
that the geisha is viewed as a higher-class “butterfly” that has slowly
drifted from pure artist and entertainer into association with the sex
industry in Japan. As most English-language literature focuses on the aesthetic
aspects and roles of the geisha, this work goes past the makeup and kimono
and reveals to the world the not-so-glamorous aspects, and true-life stories
of the geisha and her contemporary mizu shobai counterparts. Through
the use of her own experiences and interviews with individuals ranging
from gangsters, to geisha, to bar hostesses, Lewis provides an excellent
look into the personal lives and true stories of the women of the “floating
world” of the Japanese entertainment industry.
--Neely Schmidt
Matsuoka, Takashi. Cloud of Sparrows.
New York: Delacorte Press, 2002.
Cloud of Sparrows
is a pop fiction novel with a fairly complex and invigorating plot. The
story, set on the brink of the new year in 1861, takes place in an exoticized
old Japan; samurai, swords, civil warfare, a beautiful geisha, and
Zen values figure prominently here. As well as the romantically portrayed
Japanese characters, there are three Christian missionaries: Zephaniah,
Emily, and Matthew.
Once the missionaries reach
this completely foreign nation, they are taken under the wing of Lord Genji,
the Great Lord of Akaoka, and leader of the Okumichi clan in Edo. The evil
leader of the Shogun secret police, Kawakami, wants Genji dead more than
anything. Well aware of their danger, and led by his own prophesies, Lord
Genji realizes they all must escape Edo, and that he must stand up to Kawakami
and save his clan from extinction. The “outsiders,” Heiko (a geisha and
undercover spy), Genji, Genji’s uncle Lord Shigeru (a famous swordsman
and samurai), and Genji’s bodyguard, Hide all go on a perilous journey
through snow storms and fight off numerous attacks to the Okumichi
safe-haven, which is the beautiful castle, Cloud of Sparrows. After
many gruesome deaths, blossoming loves, and lives heroically saved, the
Okumichi clan survives…for now.
The portrayal of the one
and only geisha character, Heiko, is very interesting and unique. Matsuoka
makes her a hero, giving her many war-like masculine abilities. In battle,
Heiko fights disguised as a man beside her male counterparts and kills
ruthlessly. Her life in the Floating World is actually never described
other than to say that she is considered to be the most beautiful and famous
geisha in all of Japan. Though her representation does not mesh with
what real geisha of the time or even fantasy geisha of the 1860s, her figure
becomes an odd contrast against the historical backdrop of the novel.
Heiko the geisha, like the samurai in the novel, serves to embody a fabulous,
fictional Japanese past.
--Sarah Murphy
Ogasawara, Yuko. Office Ladies and
Salaried Men: Power, Gender, and Work in Japanese Companies. Berkeley:
University of California,1998
Stereotypes about geisha
are not the only stereotypes of women that exist in Japan. The office lady
is one figure that carries an image separate from reality. Office Ladies
and Salaried Men: Power, Gender, and Work in Japanese Companies addresses
the woman’s role in the Japanese office. The book does so with the intention
of revealing its complexity. The author is intent on not oversimplifying
the issues, and each chapter is dedicated to disclosing a different layer
of the topic. In the introduction, Ogasawara writes of the questions she
intends to answer which include how women enjoy independence despite their
“limited role in the economy,” what influence women have on men, how women
exercise control, and at what level women voice their opinions “in the
public sphere.” (3) Within the chapters she goes about addressing these
questions by looking at indicators such as women’s employment patterns,
relationships among female workers, why office ladies don’t protest unfair
treatment, in what ways office ladies hold power in the work place, how
women express their opinions of men, and acts of resistance. The book also
contains a conclusion in which the author sums up her findings of the women’s
situations. Ironically, it is the office lady’s lack of power that empowers
her, because unlike her male counterpart, she has few benefits to protect
and little to fear. Also, the male worker is highly dependent on the office
lady’s efficiency and, knowing this, both recognize her importance in the
workplace. Women have many different forms of resistance which they exercise
collectively, and in doing so, reinforce the stereotype many males have
that women get carried away my emotion and do not act rationally. She ends
the book with the idea that while the future of the office lady is unclear,
increase in programs to better utilize the female worker including performance
reviews will undoubtedly change the female worker as well as the total
structure of the Japanese office. Ogasawara ends the book with a series
of appendix detailing her research.--Brandi Jones
Scott, A. C. The Flower and Willow
World: A Study of the Geisha. Kingswood, Surrey, Great Britain: The
Windmill Press Ltd, 1959.
Scott seems to have written
this book as a beginner’s guide to geisha for one who knows nothing of
the subject. In the beginning of the book, he combines China and Japan
for many of the descriptions. This novel is an outsider’s look inside
the world of the geisha. It is not an in-depth, first hand experience
of what the world of a geisha is like. Simply, it is a general overview
of the history, performances, and how the world of the geisha has changed
over time. It begins with the Chinese entertainers and their impact
on Japanese entertainers that later became known as geisha and then moves
into the semi-modern world of the late 1950s. He emphasizes how important
it is for a geisha to be an expert entertainer who can sing and dance well,
and dedicates an entire section of the book to their singing and dancing
skills. The writer’s point-of-view is passive, impartial, and is
an observer instead of being opinionated. He tries to tell both sides
of the story of being a geisha. For example, he talks about how some
Japanese people are against the modernization of geisha, but then points
out that “in spite of [their] modern make-up and fashionable hair-style,
[their] manners, appearance and gestures are calculated to preserve the
feminine personality of old Japan rather than the new.” This book utilizes
simple language, photography, and illustrations to help explain to the
reader the basics of what geisha are.
Scott writes that during
occupation (1945-52), around 50,000 Japanese women were prostitutes; however,
Scott argues that they were separate from the geisha quarters. He
adds that many prostitutes tried to emulate the geisha, and in doing so,
tarnished the geisha's reputation. As a response to this infringement
on their territory, the geisha chose to "tighten up the terms of recruitment
to the quarter, make training in the various arts compulsory, and impose
strict penalties or expulsion on those who gave the quarter a bad name."
An idea came about that the name geisha had become so tainted that it needed
to be changed; however, this would mean leaving behind the name that the
"real" geisha had been using for centuries. So the name was kept
in hopes that as time went on, the name would regain its respectful meaning
and leave behind the tainted association with prostitutes. Scott
writes only briefly about the prostitutes acting like geisha, and ignores
the cultural and economic forces that separate women into allegedly good
geisha and disreputable prostitutes.--Jennifer Griffin
Sherwin, Hiroko. Eight Million
Gods and Demons. New York: PLUME, of Penguin
Group, USA, 2001.
This work of historical
fiction follows the three generations of a Japanese family from the late
19th century to the end of World War II. The story begins with the
marriage of Emi, a young musician, and Taku, a noble politician rising
in status. Everything seems to be going beautifully with their life
together, except for the fact that Emi’s poor health prevents them from
having children. Finally, Emi births a boy – Jun – but seemingly
too late to save her marriage. To Emi's dismay, she discovers that
Taku has bought out a geisha's contract and brought the geisha to live
in his “second household” – Hana, a beautiful but mean-spirited geisha,
is able to provide him with a normal wife and many children. Sherwin,
uses Emi’s voice to represent Japan’s patriarchal mores that allows a man
to have more than one household. When long-suffering Emi dies, Taku
brings Jun into Hana’s household, where he grows to love his stepsiblings
and even his new step-mother. From this point on, the story is similar
to any step-family’s, with the twists and turns of parental relations and
sibling interactions.
Sherwin takes readers on
a tour of Japanese history, countryside, and values: she explores Japan’s
imperialist attitude toward Korea and China, the great Kanto Earthquake,
the westernization of Japan, and (perhaps most extensively) World War II
and the overbearing pressure to show patriotism. She paints a believable
portrait of the changing historical and cultural landscape of modern Japan.
The narrative is chronological, except for a few flashbacks. I would
recommend that students read this if they want to get an overall sense
of life for this era, because Sherwin does a detailed job of portraying
everyday middle-class life. She also clearly delineates the geisha/wife
relationship – Emi is obviously a victim, but neither Taku nor Hana is
to blame. She is sympathetic to Emi, but also, surprisingly, to the
geisha. While Hana is the “other woman,” Sherwin shows the difficulties
that forced her into the geisha life to begin with. Taku feels a
huge amount of remorse for betraying Emi, but he truly loves both women,
and this is utterly acceptable to the Japanese. --Teresa Lee
Sneider, Vern. The Teahouse
of the August Moon. New York: Putnam, 1951.
This comedic novel, written
shortly before the end of the U.S. occupation of Japan, illustrates the
military's efforts to reconstruct Japan. It shows these happenings
through the vantage point of both the blindly ambitious Colonel Wainright
Purdy III and the practical and flexible Captain Jeff Fisby. The
opening explains the current situation in the occupied territories, as
well as outlining future plans and expectations of the military personel
presently there. Clearly a satire, the novel lampoons the efforts
of the Americans to westernize Japan, exaggerating the misinterpretations
to comedic effect. Captain Fisby, overwhelmed by his station, subordinates,
and citizens under his command, who exploit every loophole to shirk work,
through his every day encounters begins to discover that the American way
is not necessarily the right way, and illustrates the thinking man on the
side of the U.S. This change is brought about through the addition
of the geisha to the village under his control. Through the villagers'
extravagant demands and the way in which they mezmerise the villagers,
he begins to see something worthwhile to what the Japanese had. It
is only through the rebuilding of structures and agriculture important
to the geisha that the villagers really show any initiative or effort at
all. Colonel Purdy alternatively is not placed under such stresses,
and instead blindly follows the mandates passed down to him from command,
enforcing rules and regulations that simply don’t work with the existing
culture and society. The novel appears to have been written with
a desire to call into account the actions of the US forces engaged in the
occupation of Japan, and bring about a greater general understanding of
not only that situation, but of Japanese culture in the post-WWII environment.--Ryan
Kubin
•
|