CV

THE BET
 

Education

Ph.D., Philosophy, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, expected August 2008

Dissertation: The Synthesis of Concepts: Inferentialism and Semantic Theory in Hume, Kant and Hegel

Committee: Jay Rosenberg (Director), Jesse Prinz, Alan Nelson, William Lycan, Marc Lange, Gerald Postema

M.A., Philosophy, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, 2003

Thesis: Absolute Relativism

Committee: Gerald Postema (Director), William Lycan, David Reeve

B.A., Philosophy, Bard College, 2001

   

Areas of Specialization

Kant, Modern Philosophy

   


Areas of Competence

Metaphysics, Philosophy of Language, Philosophy of Mind, German Idealism

   

Refereed Journal Papers

“Hume’s Impression/Idea Distinction” Hume Studies, 32, 1 (April 2006): 119-139

“A (Sellarsian) Kantian Critique of Hume’s Theory of Concepts” Pacific Philosophical Quarterly, 88, 4 (December 2007): 445-457

“Hegel’s Account of Rule-Following” Inquiry, 51, 3 (October 2008)

“Sellars on Hume and Kant on Representing Complexes” European Journal of Philosophy, forthcoming

“Inferentialism and the Transcendental Deduction” Kantian Review, forthcoming

   

Invited Papers

"The Premise That Even Hume Must Accept" Self, Language, and World: Essays to celebrate the work of Jay F. Rosenberg. Eds. Jim O'Shea and Eric Rubenstein

   

Presentations

“Sellars on Hume and Kant on Representing Complexes” Meaning and Modern Empiricism, Virginia Tech, April 2008

“Sellars on Hume and Kant on Representing Complexes” Carolina Philosophy Retreat, Summer 2007

"Inferentialism and the Transcendental Deduction" Carolina Philosophy Retreat, Summer 2006

"A Kantian Critique of Hume's Theory of Concepts" Work-In -Progress Talk, Univeristy of North Carolina, Fall 2005

"Hume's Impression/Idea Distinction" Carolina Philosophy Retreat, Summer 2005


   

Dissertation Abstract

The Synthesis of Concepts: Inferentialism and Semantic Theory in Hume, Kant and Hegel

I re-cast the history of Modern philosophy as a debate about the nature and content of mental representations. Hume is a relationalist who believes that content is fixed by a relation between a mental entity and that which it represents. Kant, on the other hand, rejects relationalism on the grounds that it makes impossible our representing as such a world of objects bearing lawful relations to one another. Since he argues that this is necessary for representing oneself as a single, unified subject of experience persisting through time, he concludes that relationalism is untenable. Kant presents inferentialism—the thesis that the content of representation is constituted by that representation’s role in a system of inference—as a viable alternative to relationalism. Hegel accepts the Kantian picture, emphasizes the normativity involved in the inferential articulation of concepts, and argues that this is an essentially social affair. By reading these figures in this way I am able to reveal the motivations behind their semantic programs and uncover arguments that have been under appreciated in scholarship on Modern philosophy and in contemporary semantic theory. The most significant of these is Kant’s argument from the necessary co-representation of self and world to an inferentialist theory of conceptual content.


   

Editorial Work

Referee, Society for Philosophy and Psychology, 2007

Editorial Assistant, Wilfrid Sellars: Fusing the Images. Jay Rosenberg. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007

 

   


Fellowships and Awards

Henry Horace Williams Fellowship, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, September 2001-May 2002


   

Teaching Experience

University of North Carolina/Chapel Hill:

Full Responsibility: Main Problems in Philosophy (three times), Great Works in Philosophy (twice), Modern Philosophy (three times), Existentialism, Philosophy of Science

Teaching Assistant: Logic, Introduction to Ethics, Main Problems in Philosophy


   

Graduate Courses Taken (* indicates audit)

Hume, Don Garrett

Kant*, Jay Rosenberg Kant, Andrew Janiak

Modern Philosophy*, Alan Nelson

Hegel, Gerald Postema Sellars*, Jay Rosenberg

Philosophy of Language, Dorit Bar-On

Concepts, Jesse Prinz Sellars, Quine, Wittgenstein, Marc Lange

Philosophy of Mind, Richard Zaffron

Relativism*, Jesse Prinz & Dorit Bar-On Epistemology*, Jay Rosenberg

Wittgenstein*, Jay Rosenberg

Ontology, Thomas Hofweber Skepticism and Virtue Epistemology, William Lycan

Philosophy of Science, John Roberts

Causation, Marc Lange Normative Concepts, Geoff Sayre-McCord

Aristotle, Edward Galligan

Plato, David Reeve Plato’s Republic*, David Reeve

Self-Knowledge, Dorit Bar-On

Utilitarianism, Susan Wolf Logic, Mike Resnik

   

Departmental Service

Representative to the Graduate Committee, Fall 2005 – Spring 2006

Fellow of the Parr Center for Ethics, Fall 2005

Faculty Liaison, Fall 2004 – Spring 2005

   


References

Jay Rosenberg, Taylor Grandy Professor of Philosophy, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. jfr@email.unc.edu, (919) 962-3322

Don Garrett, Professor of Philosophy, New York University. don.garrett@nyu.edu, (212) 995-4179

Alan Nelson, Professor Of Philosophy, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. anelson@unc.edu, (919) 962-3030

Jesse Prinz, Professor of Philosophy, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. jesse@subcortex.com, (919) 962-3323