Question: what is
misogyny? In what societies is it found?
Mernissi, Chapter 3: A
Tradition of Misogyny (1)
- the transmitter of the offending hadith, Abu Bakra
(not to be confused with the Caliph Abu Bakr!)
- reportedly, feminine rule in Persia denounced by
the Prophet
- researching the commentary on al-Bukhari's Sahih--
actually on the occasion of the Battle of the Camel
- background of Abu Bakra-- former slave in Ta'if,
freed on the conquest of the city, who then became a notable of Basra,
though he lacked a genealogy
- the problem of dubious paternity in the case of
temporary marriage
- A'isha argues opposition to an unjust caliph who
tolerated the murder of `Uthman, rather than submission
- undemocratic debate in the mosque of Basra
- Abu Bakra opposes civil war, objecting to a woman
leader (he reports after the battle)-- was this principled opposition,
or something personal and opportunistic?
- Abu Bakra's conviction for false testimony in a
case of adultery, which requires four adult male eyewitnesses
- resulting controversy over the reliability of this
hadith
Chapter 4: A Tradition of Misogyny (2)
- stories of pilgrimage to the Prophet, told by the
author's grandmother
- learning the Qur'an at a harsh school
- a hadith on women disrupting ritual prayer -- how
could this have been said by the Prophet? transmitter: Abu Hurayra
("Kitten Man")
- the prayer direction (qibla) changed from
Jerusalem to Mecca: political questions in relation to Judaism
- a contrary tradition by A'isha
- Abu Hurayra a former sun worshiper -- connections
to Yemen and the Queen of Sheba -- who may have had gender issues about
women and cats, in conflict with A'isha over hadith
- debates about sex, menstruation, and purity during
Ramadan, corrected by Aisha
- another hadith about women and bad luck refuted by
A'isha (but her response is not mentioned by al-Bukhari!)
- other anti-women had teeth transmitted by
`Abdullah ibn `Umar, a noted ascetic
- Zarkashi's (14th-century) book on Aisha's
contributions to hadith, rediscovered in 1939, and her disputes with
Abu Hurayra
- defenses of Abu Hurayra's prodigious memory (5300
hadith), contrasted with others who took hadith with the utmost
seriousness
Part Two: Medina in Revolution: the Three Fateful Years
chapter 5: The Hijab, the Veil
- descent of the veil during the year 5/627: a
curtain on the private quarters of the Prophet's residence, when guests
stayed too late after his marriage to Zaynab
- Qur'an 33:53, "the verse of hijab", revealed as
the Prophet dropped a curtain (sitr)-- the "occasion for revelation"
explaining the circumstance of a particular verse
- Muhammad's tribulations during that period:
military reversal at Uhud after the success at Badr in year 2, failure
to defeat Meccans
- sura 33 also describes Battle of the Trench (siege
of Mecca)
- evident purpose of the verse is to encourage tact
- multiple meanings of hijab, including curtain
concealing a King, or the veiling of consciousness in Sufi mysticism;
basic meaning of separation and protection
- negative meaning of in ability to perceive
- restriction of women as a theme in modern Islam,
based on republication of medieval authorities
- woman's body as symbolic of the community that
must be controlled in a modern situation
- the division of public and private space
Question: how can
Mernissi cast doubt on hadith transmitters, but at the same time use
other texts to establish an alternative account of early Islamic
history?