CMSE Online Front Page
ProgramGuide
courses and workshops
NewsLink math/science education news
Sitefinder access to teaching resources
FeatureIndex browse our past features
AboutCMSE mission, staff, reports
SiteIndex complete table of contents

Shortest Days

Doesn't it seem dark on early December evenings? And it is dark, because every year the earliest sunset falls sometime around December 7 or 8, two full weeks before the shortest day of the year. TV meteorologists like Greg Fishel love to point this out to us, but they don't have time to explain it. What's going on?

Let's start with some data. The following sunrise, transit, and sunset times times were computed for Chapel Hill in 1997, using the popular planetarium software package Voyager II. ("Transit" is when the Sun appears due south in the sky; it's the time of local noon.) The times don't vary much across our area, or from year to year.

Date

Sunrise (am)

Transit (pm)

Sunset (pm)

Day length

November 23

7:00

12:03

5:04

10 hr 4 min

December 7

7:13

12:08

5:02

9 hr 49 min

December 21

7:23

12:14

5:06

9 hr 43 min

January 4

7:27

12:21

5:15

9 hr 48 min

January 18

7:25

12:26

5:29

10 hr 4 min

As you see, the length of the day does just what we would think: it decreases to a minimum around the time of the Winter Solstice (December 21 or thereabouts) and then it increases, reversing the path it took on the way down. On January 18, four weeks after the Solstice, the day will have the same length it had on November 23, four weeks before the Solstice. But sunrise and sunset will both be 25 minutes later, so evenings in mid January will be much brighter, and mornings much darker, than they were in late November.

We can see the culprit: the time of transit, which is astronomical noon, drifts later and later, by about two and half minutes per week, throughout this period. It's as if the Sun were slow: every day it shows up later for noon!

The cause of this odd tardiness was discovered by Johannes Kepler (1571-1630), the German astronomer who was the first to understand the true shape of planetary orbits. As Kepler discovered, the orbit of the Earth is not a circle or some complicated combination of circles; it is an ellipse. Instead of having a center, an ellipse has two foci. A point on the ellipse has the property that the sum of its distances from these two foci is a constant. Kepler found that the orbit of a planet is an ellipse with the Sun at one of its foci.

This means the Earth is closer to the Sun at some times that at others. Surprisingly, the Earth is actually closest to the Sun during the Northern Hemisphere winter (this causes our winters to be milder than they would be otherwise). The time of closest approach, called perihelion, occurs around January 4, two weeks after the Winter Solstice.

Now the Sun is a powerful center of gravity, of course, and as the Earth approaches the Sun it speeds up, pulled by the Sun's gravity. During the winter, we are moving faster through space than we are during the summer.

Now what makes the Sun seem to move across the sky is the Earth's rotation, which does not change its length more than a tiny fraction of a millisecond from day to day. Astronomers have measured that the Earth turns once on its axis in 23 hours 56 minutes 4 seconds. If we measure this period of time, starting when the Sun is due south, then at its end we'll be facing the same direction in space we were before. But the Sun won't appear in quite the same direction, because we've also moved 1/365 of the way around the Earth's orbit ellipse. On the average, it takes another 3 minutes 56 seconds for continued rotation to bring the Sun back to due south.

"On the average." When the Earth moves faster in its orbit, it takes a little more time to bring the Sun back to its highest point in the southern sky, and when the Earth moves slower, it takes a little less time. In the winter, when the Earth is speeding past its closest approach to the Sun, the extra time required comes to a maximum. Local noon gets later every day, as we see in the data.

Now think about this a moment. This means the longest days are in the winter! In the middle of the winter, the Earth needs 40 or 50 seconds more than 24 hours to bring the Sun from one noon to the next, and winter days are actually about 90 seconds longer than summer days. Of course, here we're talking about the entire day, from one noon to the next, and not the period of daylight. By this measure, New Year's Day is one of the longest days of the year.

FEEDBACK: We'd be happy to have your comments and suggestions.

 Internet Sources

SKY Online
A great place to start searching for any kind of information in astronomy, this well-known site is maintained by Sky Publishing, the publishers of Sky and Telescope. Updated daily, SKY Online always has the latest news plus a huge collection of resources and links.
Skywatcher's Diary
From the Abrams Planetarium at Michigan State, a daily guide to what to look for in the sky. The Diary always mentions annual milestones such as the Winter Solstice and perihelion. The site includes numerous links to other skywatching sites.
Morehead Planetarium's Guide to the Universe
Maintained by the Morehead Planetarium here at UNC Chapel Hill, this site is a good source of basic astronomy information. Designed for the general public, it's a particularly good site for students and for beginners in astronomy.
Universe in the Classroom
A newsletter for teachers published by the Astronomical Society of the Pacific; it's "designed for teachers who have some interest, but not much knowledge, of astronomy." Archived online you'll find several dozen articles, including To Every Season There is a Reason. Everything on this site is also available in Spanish.
Bad Astronomy
This delightful site, dedicated to debunking misconceptions about astronomy, is maintained by Phil Plait, an astronomy professor at the University of Virginia. Two of the misconceptions he tackles are "The seasons are caused by the changing distance between the Sun and the Earth" and "The seasons start at the time of the solstice or equinox." Plait has another fun site, Bite-Sized Astronomy of the Week, which provides a "snack" of astronomical information each week.
AstroEd: Astronomy Education Resources
An extensive collection of astronomy education links maintained by the University of Washington.

 

Posted December 1, 1997. Features remain online as long as they remain current; they may be updated if new information becomes available.

Copyright © 1997, Center for Mathematics and Science Education. Teachers have permission to duplicate this page for use in teaching their own classes. All other rights reserved. You are welcome to link to this page, but do not copy its contents.

http://www.unc.edu/depts/cmse/nature/snowbird.html
Center for Mathematics and Science Education
CB # 3500, 309 Peabody Hall
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
Chapel Hill, NC 27599-3500
PHONE: voice (919) 966-5922; fax (919) 962-0588

CMSE Online Front Page
ProgramGuide
courses and workshops
NewsLink math/science education news
Sitefinder access to teaching resources
FeatureIndex browse our past features
AboutCMSE mission, staff, reports
SiteIndex complete table of contents