Whether migratory animals can determine their global position by detecting features of the Earth's magnetic field has long been debated. To do this an animal must perceive (at least) two distinct magnetic parameters, each of which must vary in a different direction across the Earth's surface. There has been no evidence that any animal can perceive two such magnetic features, and whether 'magnetic maps' exist at all has remained controversial. Several populations of sea turtles undergo transoceanic migrations before returning to nest on or near the same beaches where they themselves hatched. Along the migratory routes, all or most locations have unique combinations of magnetic field intensity and field line inclination. It has been demonstrated that hatchling loggerhead turtles can distinguish between different magnetic inclination angles. Here we report that turtles can also distinguish between different field intensities found along their migratory route. Thus sea turtles possess the minimal sensory abilities necessary to approximate global position using a bicoordinate magnetic map.
Loggerhead sea turtle hatchlings (Caretta caretta L.) emerge from
underground nests, scramble to the sea and begin a transoceanic migration
by swimming away from their natal beach and into the open ocean. Evidence
suggests that hatchlings sequentially use three different sets of cues to
maintain orientation during their initial migration offshore. While on the
beach, hatchlings find the ocean by crawling towards the lower, brighter
seaward horizon and away from the dark, elevated silhouettes of vegetation
and dunes. Upon entering the ocean, turtles initially orient seawards by
swimming into waves, which can be detected as orbital movements from under
water.
Laboratory experiments have demonstrated that turtles can transfer a
course initiated on the basis of waves or visual cues to a course mediated
by a magnetic compass. Thus, by setting a magnetic course on the basis of
nearshore cues that indicate the seaward direction, hatchlings may
continue on offshore headings after entering deep water beyond sight of
land.
Sea turtles may use the earth's magnetic field not only as a cue for
compass orientation but also as a source of worldwide positional
information. Recent experiments have demonstrated that loggerheads can
detect subtle differences in magnetic field inclination and intensity, two
geomagnetic features that vary across the surface of the earth. Because
most nesting beaches and oceanic regions are marked by a unique
combination of these features, these findings raise the possibility that
adult sea turtles navigate using a bicoordinate magnetic map.
The western Atlantic spiny lobster Panulirus argus undergoes an
annual migration and is also capable of homing to specific dens in its
coral reef environment. Relatively little is known, however, about the
orientation cues that lobsters use to guide their movements. To determine
whether lobsters can orient to the earth's magnetic field, divers
monitored the orientation of lobsters tethered inside magnetic coil
systems submerged offshore in the Florida Keys, USA. Each coil could be
used to reverse either the horizontal or vertical component of the earth's
field.
Tethered lobsters walking inside the coils often established and
maintained consistent courses towards specific directions. After a lobster
had established a course, it was exposed to one of three conditions: (1) a
reversal of the horizontal component of the earth's field; (2) a reversal
of the vertical component of the earth's field; or (3) no change in the
ambient field (controls). Lobsters subjected to the horizontal field
reversal deviated significantly from their initial courses. In contrast,
control lobsters and those subjected to the reversed vertical field did
not.
These results demonstrate that spiny lobsters possess a magnetic compass
sense. Because inverting the vertical component of the earth's field had
no effect on orientation, the results suggest that the lobster compass is
based on field polarity and thus differs from the inclination compasses of
birds and sea turtles. The magnetic compass of lobsters may function in
homing behavior, in guiding the autumn migration or in both.
Western Atlantic spiny lobsters (Panulirus argus) are superb underwater navigators. Spiny lobsters perform dramatic seasonal offshore migrations and have also been shown to locate and home to specific den sites within the elaborate coral reef environment in which they live. How these animals perform such complex orientation tasks is not known. The study reported here was designed to explore the sensory mechanisms that spiny lobsters use to orient in and around a familiar patch reef environment. Our results show that, in the absence of visual cues, lobsters displaced a short (50 m) distance off the reef do not initially (i.e. within 20min) travel towards their dens or return to the patch reef where their dens are located. Instead, the headings lobsters follow are significantly correlated to the direction of local hydrodynamic cues and, specifically, to the direction of approaching wave surge. Results from ultrasonic tracking experiments over longer periods (24 h) suggest that displaced lobsters are able to relocate the reef where they were captured, even without visual cues. These results suggest that hydrodynamic cues may provide useful and immediate directional information to lobsters within the local environment of the home reef.
At the beginning of their offshore migration, hatchling sea turtles enter
the ocean at night and establish a course away from land by swimming
directly into oceanic waves. How turtles can detect wave direction while
swimming under water in darkness, however, has not been explained.
Objects in a water column beneath the surface of the ocean describe a
circular movement as waves pass above. In principle, swimming turtles
might, therefore, detect wave direction by monitoring the sequence of
accelerations they experience under water. To determine whether loggerhead
(Caretta caretta L.) and green turtle (Chelonia mydas L.)
hatchlings can detect wave direction in this way, we constructed a wave
motion simulator to reproduce in air the circular movements that occur
beneath small ocean waves. Hatchlings suspended in air and subjected to
movements that simulated waves approaching from their right sides
attempted to turn right, whereas movements that simulated waves from the
left elicited left-turning behavior. Movements simulating waves from
directly in front of the turtles elicited little turning in either
direction.
The results demonstrate that hatchling sea turtles can determine the
propagation direction of ocean waves by monitoring the circular movements
that occur as waves pass above. Although sea turtles are the first animals
shown to be capable of detecting wave direction in this way, such an
orientation mechanism may be widespread among other transoceanic migrants
such as fish and cetaceans.
For animals that migrate long distances, the magnetic field of the earth
provides not only a possible cue for compass orientation, but a potential
source of world-wide positional information. At each location on the
globe, the geomagnetic field lines intersect the earth's surface at a
specific angle of inclination. Because inclination angles vary with
latitude, an animal able to distinguish between different field
inclinations might, in principle, determine its approximate latitude. Such
an ability, however, has never been demonstrated in any animal.
We studied the magnetic orientation behavior of hatchling loggerhead sea
turtles (Caretta caretta L.) exposed to earth-strength magnetic
fields of different inclinations. Hatchlings exposed to the natural field
of their natal beach swam eastward, as they normally do during their
offshore migration. In contrast, those subjected to an inclination angle
found on the northern boundary of the North Atlantic gyre (their presumed
migratory path) swam south-southwest. Hatchlings exposed to an inclination
angle found near the southern boundary of the gyre swam in a northeasterly
direction, and those exposed to inclination angles they do not normally
encounter, or to a field inclination found well within the northern and
southern extremes of the gyre, were not significantly oriented.
These results demonstrate that sea turtles can distinguish between
different magnetic inclination angles and perhaps derive from them an
approximation of latitude. Most sea turtles nest on coastlines that are
aligned approximately north-south, so that each region of nesting beach
has a unique inclination angle associated with it. We therefore
hypothesize that the ability to recognize specific inclination angles may
largely explain how adult sea turtles can identify their natal beaches
after years at sea.
During their natal migration, hatchling loggerhead sea turtles (Caretta
caretta L.) establish courses towards the open ocean and maintain them
after swimming beyond sight of land. Laboratory experiments have
demonstrated that swimming hatchlings can orient using the earth's
magnetic field. For the magnetic compass to function in guiding the
offshore migration, however, hatchlings must inherit or acquire a magnetic
directional preference that reliably leads them towards the open sea.
On land, hatchlings find the ocean using light cues associated with the
seaward horizon. To determine whether turtles might acquire a preference
for a specific magnetic direction on the basis of such cues, we studied
the magnetic orientation of turtles initially exposed to light from either
magnetic east or west. Hatchlings that had been exposed to light in the
east subsequently oriented eastward when tested in darkness, whereas those
that had been exposed to light in the west swam westward. Reversing the
magnetic field resulted in a corresponding shift in orientation,
indicating that the turtles were orienting to the ambient magnetic field.
These results demonstrate that light cues can set the preferred direction
of magnetic orientation by loggerhead hatchlings. We therefore hypothesize
that hatchlings initially establish a seaward course using visual cues
available on or near land, then maintain the course using magnetic cues as
they migrate into the open sea.
This paper has no abstract.
Recent experiments have demonstrated that hatchling loggerhead sea turtles can orient using the earth's magnetic field. To investigate the functional characteristics of the loggerhead magnetic compass, we tested the orientation of hatchlings tethered inside a circular arena surrounded by a coil system that could be used to reverse the vertical and horizontal components of the ambient field. Hatchlings tested in darkness in the earth's magnetic field were significantly oriented in an eastward direction. Inverting the vertical magnetic field component resulted in an approximate reversal of orientation direction, whereas reversing both the vertical and horizontal components together did not. The hatchlings failed to orient in a horizontal field of earth-strength intensity. These results provide evidence that the magnetic compass of loggerheads is an inclination (axial) compass, functionally similar to that of birds.
Diverse animals can orient to the earth 's magnetic field but the mechanism or mechanisms underlying magnetic field detection have not been determined. Behavioral and neurophysiological results suggest that the transduction process underlying magnetic compass orientation in vertebrates is light-dependent, a finding consistent with theoretical models proposing that magnetoreception involves a modulation of the response of retinal photoreceptors to light. We report, however, that leatherback sea turtle (Dermochelys coriacea) hatchlings orient to the geomagnetic field in complete darkness. Thus, light-dependence is not a universal feature of vertebrate magnetic compasses
This paper has no abstract.
Minutes after emerging from underground nests, hatchling green turtles
(Chelonia mydas L.) enter the sea and begin a migration towards the
open ocean. To test the hypothesis that migrating hatchlings use wave cues
to maintain their seaward headings, we released turtles offshore during
unusual weather conditions when waves moved in atypical directions.
Hatchlings swam into approaching waves in all experiments, even when doing
so resulted in orientation back towards land. These data suggest that
green turtle hatchlings normally maintain seaward headings early in the
offshore migration by using wave propagation direction as an orientation
cue. Because waves and swells reliably move towards shore in shallow
coastal areas, swimming into waves usually results in movement towards the
open sea.
The physiological mechanisms that underlie wave detection by sea turtle
hatchlings are not known. Calculations indicate that, at the depth at
which hatchlings swim, accelerations produced beneath typical waves and
swells along the Florida coast are sufficient to be detected by the
vertebrate inner ear. We therefore hypothesize that hatchlings determine
wave direction while under water by monitoring the sequence of horizontal
and vertical accelerations that occur as waves pass above.
Diverse animals can orient using geomagnetic cues, but little is known about the neurophysiological mechanisms that underlie magnetic field detection. The marine mollusc Tritonia diomedea (Bergh) has a magnetic sense and its nervous system is amenable to cellular-level electrophysiological analysis. In a semi-intact whole-animal preparation, intracellular recordings from the large, visually identifiable neurons left pedal 5 (LPe5) and right pedal 5 (RPe5) in the brain of Tritonia revealed enhanced electrical activity in response to changes in ambient earth strength magnetic fields. No such changes in activity were observed in approximately 50 other neurons subjected to identical magnetic stimuli. The responses of LPe5 were characterized by increases in spiking frequency occurring about 6-16 min. after the ambient magnetic field had been rotated to a new position. The response was abolished when the brain had been isolated from the periphery of the animal by severing nerves, a procedure that also transected prominent neurites of LPe5. We hypothesize that LPe5 is one component of a neural circuit mediating detection of the earth's magnetic field or orientation to it.
Laboratory experiments were conducted to test the ability of loggerhead sea turtle hatchlings (Caretta caretta L.) to orient using the magnetic field of the earth. Hatchlings were tethered to a rotatable lever-arm apparatus which tracked swimming orientation in complete darkness. Hatchlings tested in the earth's magnetic field were non-randomly oriented with a mean angle of 42 degrees; those tested under an earth-strength field with a reversed horizontal component were also non-randomly oriented, but with a mean angle of 196 degrees. The distributions under the two magnetic field conditions were significantly different, indicating that loggerhead sea turtle hatchlings can detect the magnetic field of the earth and use it as a cue in orientation.
Sea turtle hatchlings emerge from underground nests on oceanic beaches and
immediately confront two separate problems in orientation. First they
must locate the ocean and crawl to it; then they must swim out to sea in a
migration lasting several days.
Visual cues guide hatchlings from the nest to the sea, but little is known
about the cues used by turtles in the ocean. Nevertheless, the crawl
across the beach has long been considered essential to swimming
orientation because hatchlings released offshore without a crawl
reportedly fail to orient seaward. Here we report that hatchling
leatherback (Dermochelys coriacea) and green (Chelonia
mydas) sea turtles released offshore consistently swam toward
approaching waves and oceanic swells. Wave tank experiments confirmed
that swimming hatchlings oriented into waves. A crawl across the beach
was not a prerequisite for wave orientation in either the field or lab,
indicating that hatchling sea turtles possess two separate orientation
systems, each based on different sensory cues and capable of functioning
autonomously. The first guides hatchlings on land to the sea; the second,
based on wave detection, functions during the ocean migration.
Within minutes after emerging from underground nests, sea turtle hatchlings (Caretta caretta L.) locate and crawl to the ocean, enter the surf, then maintain oriented courses that lead them out to sea even after they no longer detect land. The cues hatchlings use, while the subject of some speculation, were unknown. Recent field studies show that hatchlings orient toward surface waves. Our experiments, conducted in a wave tank, demonstrate that loggerhead sea turtle hatchlings maintain headings toward oncoming waves. The response does not depend upon visual cues as it persists in the absence of visual light.
Behavioral experiments have demonstrated that some bacteria, flatworms, mollusks, arthropods, fish, amphibians, birds, and mammals can orient using the geomagnetic field. Despite the widespread occurrence of the magnetic sense in animals, little is known about the neurophysiological mechanisms underlying magnetic field detection. Recently, a few researchers have begun to approach the problem from an electrophysiological perspective. In this article we summarize four hypothetical transduction mechanisms and conclude with an overview of recent neurophysiological advances.
Sea turtle hatchlings emerge from underground nests, crawl to the ocean and swim out to sea. The orientation cues used to maintain offshore headings are unknown. Our field experiments suggest loggerhead hatchlings on the Atlantic coast of Florida continue on offshore headings by swimming into oceanic swells and wind-generated waves. Dependence on these cues appears complete when hatchlings are 3.0 km from shore. Because waves and swells usually approach from seaward directions, they are generally reliable guideposts.
Behavioral experiments indicated that the marine opisthobranch mollusk Tritonia diomedea can derive directional cues from the magnetic field of the earth. The magnetic direction toward which nudibranchs spontaneously oriented in the geomagnetic field showed recurring patterns of variation correlated with lunar phase, suggesting that the behavioral response to magnetism is modulated by a circa-lunar rhythm. The discovery of a magnetic sense in a mollusk with giant, reidentifiable neurons provides a unique opportunity to study the cellular mechanisms underlying magnetic field detection.
The magnetic characteristics of 15 western Atlantic spiny lobsters
(Panulirus argus) were analysed with a superconducting cryogenic
magnetometer. Each specimen possessed a significant natural remnant
magnetization (NRM) and isothermal remnant magnetization (IRM), indicating
that ferromagnetic material is present. Analyses of the distribution of
total remanence and mass-specific remanence indicate that magnetic
material is concentrated in the cephalothorax, particularly in tissue
associated with the fused thoracic ganglia. Mass-specific remanence and
the total quantity of magnetic material in the cephalothorax and abdomen
both increase as functions of carapace length.
The NRM is significantly orientated in at least four regions of the body.
The NRM of the left half of the posterior cephalothorax is directed
posteriorly, while that of the right half is oriented anteriorly. In
addition, the NRM of the middle cephalothorax is orientated toward the
right side of the animal; the NRM of the telson-uropods region is directed
toward the left. The functional significance of these regions of oriented
remanence is not known, but such a pattern could result from the ordered
alignment of permanently magnetic particles comprising a magnetoreceptor
system.