Images from the Polish cognitive scene
The present title is a travesty of the one given to a pioneering publication
on CL which appeared on the Polish market: a 1993 collection of papers, called
"Images from the Cognitive Scene" and edited by Elzbieta Gorska. Characteristically,
out of ther eleven papers that constitute the book (all written by Polish authors)
only one takes up a topic relating to Polish. Other discuss various aspects
of English. This "anglicisation" is very typical of contemporary Polish
scene. Among the few authors working within the cognitive framework the most
prominent names are those of Brygida Rudzka-Ostyn (case) Ewa Dabrowska (verbal
aspect, case) and Anna Wierzbicka (pragmatics, ethnolinguistics) - characteristically
again, all of them working in a non-Polish milieu. Otherwise, Polish data appears
only occasionally, in the form of simplified (and sometimes distorted) single
examples. This is quite discouraging, considering the fact that the insights
of many Polish representastives of "traditional" (pre-structuralist)
linguistics may be in fact seen as fully compatible with Langacker's theory
of language and grammar. Among contemporary Polish scholars, reservations about
the cognitive framework stem from the unwillingness of the older generation
to adopt new theoretical approach (terminology, notation, etc.), and, on the
other hand, from the preoccupation of younger linguists with generativist theories.
Those willing to adopt the cognitivist framework face two kinds of problems:
they are not fully familiar with the traditional Polish "roots" and/or
find the "anglicised" tools difficult to adopt to the exotic Polish
material. As the result, contributions produced so far focus upon a few traditional
areas (aspect, case and prepositions),while others, like gender, definiteness,
discourse markers, various aspects of iconicity etc. are never tackled. It is
claimed that re-focussing scholarly interests towards such topics - in cooperation
with scholars working on other Slavic languages - could add validity to the
thory while at the same time providing valuable feedback. Some examples will
be given to substantiate this claim.