Which Witch
is Which???

This letter was written by a friend as part of a discussion regarding who is what, what is which, and how do we figure out (much less explain to others) the differences. I was particularly impressed with the system she devised, and asked her permission to post it here.

By the way, when she states that she is also a "word addict," Morwyn is referring to one of my nicknames - Captain Semantics {G}.





I am another word-addict, and meanings, especially precise shades thereof, have much power for me... as well as the fact that Naming is an act of Magick. So, how about...

Pagan - a follower of any Earth-based spiritual path, who believes Deity is other than transcendent and dogmatic; not necessarily a

Witch - one who honors the God/dess/es and follows the Old Ways, however they are presented to them, and seeks to learn the Ancient Mysteries; not necessarily a

Wiccan - one who has become aligned with a specific tradition of the Old Ways, whether British Traditional, Celtic Traditional, or some other... one who honors a succession of teachers, and chooses to work in a covened setting, or at any rate within a structure involving one or several other people who may teach, grant advancement WITHIN THAT TRADITION, and the like; not necessarily a

Priest/Priestess - one who (within ANY of the aforementioned classifications) chooses to serve Deity by serving the children of the God/dess/es in providing rites of passage, spiritual counsel, and the like, as do any clergy in any other spirit path.

And scattered among all the above semantical distinctions, one may find:

Initiates - those who are "initiating" a study of the paths of the God/dess/es; or

Craft Initiates - those who have been 'initiated" into the Craft of the Wise... granted knowledge, insight, understanding, whether by human or Deific means; or

Initiates of Wicca - those who have been admitted into a tradition, handed down lineage and empowered by those who have the right, WITHIN THAT TRADITION, to grant such; or

Eclectic Witches - those for whom the power of transmutation is ever paramount, who "steal what works" (to quote Starhawk!!) and who are not concerned with alignment with a particular lineage or Trad, but "initiate" study where they will, choose freely what they may explore, and consider themselves the richer for it, whether they do it alone or companioned with others of like minds; or

Solitaries - those who, since they are "solitary" follow a path delineated by themselves alone, which may grant them any attendant insight, knowledge and blessing they choose to receive... including a personal awareness of having been "initiated" into Mystery...

...and who is to say, among all this richness, that one blossom is sweeter than all the others? But yet, the rose is not the violet, nor is either the lilac... and it is well that it is so, or gardens, and the Craft community, would be infinitely poorer and terribly boring!!

             Much love from Morwyn Aisling



"...that which we are, we are...
one equal temper of heroic hearts...
made weak by time and fate but strong in will...
to strive, to seek, to find, and not to yield."
             Alfred Lord Tennyson... "ULYSSES"



Last modified: 05 April 2000
©2000 Red Deer@pagani