The state has a potentially broad range of policy approaches for influencing academic standards. Policies range from providing incentives designed to strengthen professional self-regulation, to directly monitoring the academic quality of institutions, to freeing and facilitating market forces as a means of improving academic quality (see Table 1). Therefore we plan to carry out policy analyses of a broad range of policy instruments and practices designed to influence academic standards.

Each policy analysis will examine one quality assurance instrument, and will focus on its development and implementation. The main purpose of each paper is to inform readers about the perceived problems that led to the new policy, what the policy was intended to do, implementation problems, the identified costs, and the impacts of the policy. The analysis should enable a reader to consider the possible effectiveness of the instrument in some other political and academic environment.
 
 

Table 1
Alternative Policy Instruments for Regulating Academic Quality
Locus of Influence
Focus Professional (Self) Regulation State (Direct) Regulation Market Regulation
Research Professional Peer Judgments Research Assessments Competitive Allocation of Research Funds by State
Teaching/ Learning
  • Professional Disciplines/Organizations
  • Professional Certification/Licensure
  • External Examining Systems
  • Voluntary Accreditation
  • "Assessment Regulations" (US)
  • Academic Audits
  • Subject Assessments
  • State Certification/ Licensure
  • State-Conducted Accreditation
  • Performance-Indicators
  • National Examinations
  • Student-Based Funding and Tuition Fees
  • Information Provision
04.07.03