The United Nations, Terrorism, and Nation Building
World View Seminar on September 11 and Its Aftermath

Jim Roush

        
 

The session led off with a brief review of the structure of the United Nations (UN) and the role of its principal bodies (all located in New York): 

1) the General Assembly, with its annual and special meetings of all members; 
2) the Security Council (SC) with its 15 members focusing continually on international peace issues; and 
3) the Secretariat, headed by the Secretary-General, which executes (or coordinates the execution of) 
    the decisions of the UNGA and SC and makes recommendations to those bodies. 



The United Nations and Terrorism

Even before 11 September 2001, the UN was dealing with terrorism issues. The earliest conventions promulgated by the General Assembly date from 1963 and dealt with airplane hijackings and the safety of civil aviation. Other later conventions related to hostage taking, protecting nuclear material, marking explosives (to facilitate detection), etc. A Convention about terrorist bombings was approved by the General Assembly in 1998 and one related to the financing of terrorism in 2000. The US Government made no effort to ratify these agreements and obtain implementing legislation until after September 11th.

The Security Council passed a resolution in 1992 establishing sanctions against Libya related to the downing of the PanAm flight over Scotland. In 1996, the Council passed a resolution establishing sanctions against Sudan for its support of terrorist activity. In 1999, sanctions were voted in the Security Council against the Taliban for not turning over bin Laden and closing his training camps. 

The UN also established a Counter-Terrorism unit in Vienna, Austria as part of the UN Office for Drug Control and Crime Prevention which was established in 1997; this unit has served primarily as an information clearinghouse on techniques for preventing and/or countering terrorist activity. In the Millennium Summit Meeting of the General Assembly in September 2000, the leaders of the countries of the world in their Millennium Declaration resolved "to take concerted action against international terrorism, and to accede as soon as possible to all the relevant international conventions."

The day following the 9/11 attack, both the General Assembly and the Security Council issued resolutions condemning the attacks, expressing condolences to the victims and their families and the people and government of the United States, and urging international action to bring to justice those responsible and to take measures to prevent further terrorist activity. The Security Council went further and defined international terrorism as a threat to the peace, thereby giving victim countries the right to take unilateral action against terrorism as a self-defense measure. The Security Council's resolution (# 1373) also spelled specific actions that countries were expected to take.

The UN's actions received little press in the U.S. because the media was focusing on the invocation by the U.S. of Article V of the North Atlantic Treaty which states that an attack on one member shall be considered an attack on all members. Thus, European countries and Canada, after the 9/11 attack, provided help to the U.S. to protect its borders. Since Article V was originally included in the Treaty at the request of the Europeans so that the U.S. would automatically be involved if there were attacks on any 
European member of NATO, U.S. invocation of the provision was considered more newsworthy.

The Security Council issued another Resolution (1373) on September 28 setting forth additional actions that should be taken by member countries to prevent and suppress terrorist activities, with special emphasis on freezing funds and taking other actions to cut the supply of money for financing terrorist activity. The Council established a special counter-terrorism committee to monitor countries' responses to its resolutions and called upon all States to report to the Committee within 90 days (and later on a timetable to be established) on the steps taken to implement the resolution.

On November 12, the Security Council followed up with Resolution 1377 reiterating countries' responsibilities set forth in previous resolutions and offered to provide assistance to any country needing it, inviting such countries to get in touch with the Council's Counter-Terrorism Committee. In other words, the Council was heading off countries' excuses that they didn't have the capacity to deal with terrorism. Over 100 countries reported to the Committee within the 90-day deadline -- an unprecedented response.



The United Nations and Nationbuilding

Traditionally, nationbuilding referred to the efforts of former colonies and other less-developed countries to develop modern political structures and develop self-supporting economies. In recent years, however, the term has been used more in relation to UN peacekeeping operations and the need to "re-build" societies after conflict, often internal conflict. In this context, nationbuilding involves restoring: Internal Security, Social Structures, Political Structures, and the Economy. To be able to make progress in any of these, it frequently is necessary to carry out a major relief and resettlement program.

The UN and its affiliated organizations, with the support of individual countries in most cases, has carried out a number of successful nationbuilding missions and is still doing so in a number of former "hot spots." Afghanistan currently demonstrates what all is involved. The UN helped organize the meeting in Bonn of the various Afghan factions which resulted in an interim government and a process for moving to a new political structure. Under UN auspices, peacekeepers have been provided by some member countries and they are deployed in the Kabul area -- they will probably be needed in other areas.

The UN is taking the lead in organizing the return of refugees from neighboring countries and "displaced persons" who have moved to other parts of Afghanistan to get away from fighting. Their return to rural areas is complicated by the fact that there has been a drought for about four years and many do not have any seeds to sow even if conditions are good this year. Many will return to planting the opium poppy as a way of making money.

In the urban areas, there will be a need for jobs -- the economy must be re-started. The educational system needs to be re-vamped and re-started. Similarly, the health system need to be restored -- or created. There are UN agencies involved in all these activities. Often their funds are grossly inadequate for the job and the difference is made up by bilateral and multilateral aid programs. The UN organized a donor meeting to get pledges for Afghanistan's reconstruction -- perhaps one should say resurrection. Private voluntary agencies/nongovernmental organizations, are frequently essential partners -- being the implementers of programs, particularly at the grass roots level.

Participants in the session were provided with information about materials that are available for teaching about the UN; a set of the information materials displayed has been made available to World View. The participants expressed an interest in also knowing how to access good sources of information about current developments in the rest of the world -- they felt that what is provided by the U.S. media is inadequate and frequently biased. Sources suggested by the speaker were the following:

UN Wire -- provides an e-mail report of the day's headlines related to international (not just UN) issues (Monday through Friday), with the stories available online. To sign up, go to: www.unfoundation.org

World Press Review -- a monthly news magazine sponsored by the Stanley Foundation, the Review is published as a nonprofit, educational service to foster the exchange of information. It contains material from the press outside the U.S., e.g., the January 2002 issue had press articles from almost 20 countries. To subscribe, contact World Press Review, P.O. Box 228, Shrub Oak, NY 10588-0228 or call (914) 962-6292.

BBC World News -- a one-hour program on Public Radio at 9:00 a.m.; also a TV version at 11:00 p.m. on PBS.

For questions about the foregoing or UN publications and teaching materials, you can contact Mr. Roush at JLRoush@aol.com.