![]() |
Research | ||||
| Topic Introduction: | |||||
Recently
experts have been talking about the increasing number of cases
of obesity, especially in young children, in
the United States. While this is a growing trend, there are still
many young children, young girls in particular, who have serious body
image
problems. These girls are starving themselves attempting to achieve
the “perfect
body.” Eating disorders and poor body image have been blamed
on many things; however, one girl seems to have taken much of the
blame—Barbie.
I was, and still am a huge fan of Barbie. I spent countless
hours with her during my early childhood, and she did not seem
to have
any effect
on my mental health or body perception. I want to learn whether
I am the exception, and if Barbie presents an unattainable body
to young receptive
girls. My audience is students, like myself. Also, parents of girls ages three to eight who play with Barbie dolls. These parents may be concerned that their daughter is getting a poor body image from Barbie. Through the course of this project, I hope to answer the following questions:
|
|||||
Web
Sources: |
Back to the top | |
| Title: Fear and Loathing the Mirror Web address: http://nm-server.jrn.columbia.edu/projects/masters/bodyimage/toc.html Description: This web site is primarily about women and their pursuit for the perfect body. It also has information about how the media and society affect women and their body image. It has lots of useful diverse information, from how some are fighting against the “dying to be thin” wave, and how plastic surgery plays a role in body image problems. It also has a great timeline that describes how the “perfect” body has evolved since the middle of the 19th century. Source: Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism |
||
| Title: Exploring the role society and the media play in the development
of an Eating Disorder Web address: http://www.something-fishy.org/cultural/themedia.php Description: This is a specific section on an entire web site about eating disorders. This section gives information about how the media in general, Barbie, society, and culture affect girls’ body image from an early age. The entire web site gives information on causes, warning signs, and ways to get help for people who are suffering from or may be suffering from a distorted body image or eating disorder. Source: Something Fishy Website on Eating Disorders |
||
| Title: Children Web address: http://www.mirror-mirror.org/child.htm Description: This is a specific section on an entire web site about eating disorders. This section gives information about children and eating disorders and body image. It specifically discusses the effect that parents’ body image can have on the body image of a child. Similarly, it gives information about positive activities that can give children a better body image and higher self-esteem. Source: Mirror Mirror Eating Disorders |
||
| Title: Body Image and Advertising Web address: http://www.mediascope.org/pubs/ibriefs/bia.htm Description: This is a section of the mediascope web site discusses the effects that advertising has on body image. This site does a good job of giving statistics and breaking down the different effects that advertising has on body perception. In addition, it has a special section dedicated to discussing the effects advertising has on young boys. Source: Mediascope |
||
| Title: Getting Beyond Barbie: Children and Body Images Web address: http://www.csmonitor.com/durable/1998/12/16/fp17s1-csm.shtml Description: This site is an article from The Christian Science Monitor. It discusses how women’s preoccupation with thinness is now happening at a younger age. It gives interesting and intriguing statistics about dieting, plastic surgery, and “fear of fatness.” Source: The Christian Science Publishing Society |
||
| Sources from UNC-CH Libraries: | ||
| Print sources: | Back to the top | |
| Edut, Ophira, ed. Adiós, Barbie: Young Women Write about Body Image and Identity. Seattle: Seal Press, 1998. BF697.5.B63 A35 1998. | ||
| Tebbel, Cyndi. The Body Snatchers: How the Media Shapes Women. Sydney: Finch Pub., 2000. P94.5.W65 T43 2000. | ||
| Non-print source: | ||
| Kilbourne, Jean. Slim Hopes: Advertising and the Obsession with Thinness. Dir. by Sut Jhally. 30 min. Media Education Foundation, 1995. Videocassette. 65-V6106. | ||
| Electronic Indexes and Databases Sources: | Back to the top | |
| Berg-Cross, Linda, “How do Barbie and Ken measure up?” Psychotherapy Letter, vol.8 (April 1996): 3. Database on-line. Available from EBSCOHost, Academic Search Elite <http://www.epnet.com>. [26 January 2003]. | ||
| Lee, Janet. “Beef up, Barbie.” Women’s Sports and Fitness, vol. 15 (October 1993): 25. Database on-line. Available from EBSCOHost, Academic Search Elite <http://www.epnet.com >. [26 January 2003]. | ||
| Markey, Charlotte N., Barbara J. Tinsley, Andrea J. Ericksen, Daniel J. Ozer, Patrick M. Markey. “Preadolescents' perceptions of females' body size and shape: Evolutionary and social learning perspectives.” Journal of Youth and Adolescence, vol. 31 (April 2002): 137-147. Database on-line. Available from Infotrac General Reference Center Gold <http://infotrac.thomsonlearning.com>. [26 January 2003]. | ||
| Quindlen, Anna. “Barbie at 35.” New York Times, 10 September 1994, 19. Database on-line. Available from EBSCOHost, Academic Search Elite <http://www.epnet.com >. [26 January 2003]. | ||
| Reichenberg-Ullman, Judyth. “A High Performer with Bulimia.” Resonance: The Magazine of the International Foundation for Homeopathy, vol. 19 (June 1997): 13-18. Database on-line. Available from EBSCOHost, Alt HealthWatch <http://www.epnet.com>. [26 January 2003]. | ||
| Steenland, Sally. “Barbie and the 'Deadly Cult of Thinness'.” Knight Ridder/Tribune News Service, 7 June 1995, p607K0576. Database on-line. Available from Infotrac General Reference Center Gold <http://infotrac.thomsonlearning.com>. [26 January 2003]. | ||
Internet
Mini-Essay |
|
Pro-Anorexia
Web Sites: Therapeutic or Destructive |
|
| Countless doctors and other medical professionals
have theories and methods for “supporting” and “curing” people with
eating disorders, and these work for many people. However, recently the
anorexic community has found their own “solution”—the
Web. Today
around 400 pro-anorexia, “pro-ana,” web sites exist as
a support system to people at all stages of the disease. (1) Girls as young
as 10 visit these sites daily to feel accepted, share feelings, and get
anorexia tips. Some sites get so many hits that by mid-month the sites
are inaccessible. (2) While numbers are growing, there are only a small
percentage of anorexics that are self-proclaimed “pro-ana.” This
hard to pinpoint group is described by eating disorder specialists as a “small,
vocal, and proactive minority.” (2) Pro-anorexia sites are difficult to find now except for those who are on
the inside. This is because the National Association of Anorexia Nervosa
and Associated Disorders asked large servers like Yahoo, which was hosting
more than 100 of the sites, to take down the sites in July 2001. While
Yahoo removed the sites, the owners quickly found private servers to use
as hosts. (1) The
opinions on whether these sites are damaging both to people with eating
disorders and to those who have the potential to develop them
are divided. Dr. Rachel Russell,
a clinician specializing in eating disorders in Danbury, Conn., views
the web sites as an “honest expression of what anorexia is, complete with the ambivalence.” (1)
However, psychotherapist Steven Levenkron, who wrote the anorexic's bible, The
Best Little Girl in the World, in 1978 and Anatomy of Anorexia in 2000, says
that the sites connect with potentially treatable girls, “seducing” them
into anorexia and make the girls who run the sites feel “less lonely.” (1) |
| Notes: | Back to the top | |
| (1) Deirdre Dolan, “Learning to Love Anorexia? ‘Pro-Ana’ Web Sites Flourish,” New York Observer, 3 February 2003, p.7. Also available [Online]: Lexis-Nexis Academic [Accessed 2 February, 2003]. | ||
| (2) Rhoda Fukushima, “Some Anorexics Don’t Want to Recover,” Knight-Ridder/Tribune News Service, 11 October 2002, p.K1932. Also available [Online]: Infotrac General Reference Center Gold [Accessed 2 February, 2003]. | ||
Want
to learn more about pro-anorexia on the Web? Visit these sites: |
||
| Title of Web Page: Anorexia
Goes High Tech Web Address: http://www.time.com/time/health/article/0,8599,169660,00.html Brief Description: This article discusses whether pro-anorexic sites should be allowed. It also gives a general description of why these types of sites exist. Source of Web site: Time.com |
||
| **Title
of Web Page: Anorexic Beauty Web Address: http://www.anorexicbeauty.com/ Brief Description: A pro-anorexic page with quizzes, pictures, message boards, and a personal journal. Source of the Web site: It’s a personal site by a pro-anorexic girl. **the nature of these sites causes them to change addresses frequently, so this site may not be accessible |
||
| Title
of Web Page: Proanorexia.ca Web Address: http://www.proanorexia.ca/ Brief Description: Against the pro-anorexia media. Has information about getting help and recognizing eating disorders Source of the Web site: Proanorexia |
||
Check out the UNC site and the J-50 site |
Back to the top | |