"Consuming
Bodies" by John Clammer, pps. 197-219 in Women, Media and Consumption
in Japan
1. Before you read
the article or take notes on it, look at only the Japanese magazine photographs
included in the
article. How do you
read them? What questions and answers are important to you?
Jot these down and keep
them in mind on Thursday
when we look at paintings and photographs featuring women at the Ackland
Art
Museum. Do your questions
apply equally to magazines and to the museum pieces?
2. How are you consuming
images differently by walking through a museum and by reading a magazine
in your
room?
3. The title of Clammer's
article is a cute play on words. You can read it as "the bodies that
consume (products)"
or as "we who consume bodies
(through reading magazines)." How does Clammer develop both themes
in his
article?
4. Clammer chose some
women's magazines, men's magazines, and general magazines for his discussion.
How
does the view of the female
body change as he considers each of these three magazine types?
5. Clammer argues that
race, age, and class intersect in magazine images of the female body.
Give two examples
of this from his article.
Can you also give two examples from a current U.S. magazine?
"Reading Japanese
in Katei Gahô: the art of being an upperclass woman"
by Brian Moeran, pps.
111-142 in Women, Media and Consumption in Japan
1. What kind of magazine are we talking about?
-
Who
is the "imagined" reader and subject of the magazine Katei gahô?
-
What
sort of readership does the magazine actually have?
-
What
percentage of the magazines is made up of ads?
-
How
do you guess the magazine looks?
2. Moeran uses some terms
specific to magazines. How do you explain:
-
the magazine's
"face"
-
sell lines
-
flow
3. Explain how Western-style
and Japanese-style clothing have different meanings in the context of Katei
gahô.
4. How does Katei
gahô make use of "nostalgia, nature and tradition" in crafting
the lifestyle and concerns of the
upperclass Japanese woman?
5. Moeran talks about
how editors achieve a "flow" of images throughout an issue. How does
he say they do this?
6. On p. 135, Moeran
discusses the pleasures of reading Katei gahô enjoying a fantasy
of displacement. What does he mean by this?
|