slippage of terms
`ibadat: ritual and devotional practice, or the total
life
system? nizam
Iranian student criticism of Ayatullah Khu'i:
"He's just a religious mulla; he doesn't talk about Islam."
Augustine: On True Religion
Grotius, On the Truth of the Christian Religion
"world religions"
Talal Asad, Genealogies of Religion, pp. 200 ff.
categories of debate are dictated by Europeans
Islam (submission): perform 5 acts (5pillars), prayer, fasting, pilgrimage, alms, profession of faith -- component of social conformity
Iman (faith, belief): believe in God, angels, scriptures,
judgment
Ihsan (virtue, ): pray to God as though you see him;
and if you don't see him, know that he sees you
-- hadith (saying) of Muhammad,
Muslim (one who submits) -- social identity
Mu'min (one who believes) -- ideal
Ottoman concept of millat (religious community)