Mishler
Home Up Syllabus Mishler FocusGroup MaterialCulture Whyte FocusInterview

 

Elliot Mishler: Research Interviewing: Context and Narrative

Traditional, mainstream interviews – survey research – are inadequate and there is a need for alternative: narrative analysis.

Answers vary despite attempts at standardization and the issue of ‘meaning’ is highlighted. Reponses are stripped of meaning, loss of context.

Interviews are dependent upon natural language competences of both coders and investigators- how can you standardize this practice?

Language is indexical:

Terms take on meaning throughout the text and are dependent upon situational context – who is speaking

Interviewer and Interviewee struggle for common meaning via reformulation of questions throughout interview

Analysis is required of above points. Leads Mishler to explore "how is the narrative influenced by the interview situation and what role does the interviewer play in its production?" (92)

Regardless of the type of narrative analysis that is used, main advantage is the position that respondents’ accounts are stories, meaningful discourse.

Stories appear and re-appear in interviews and reports need to focus on how stories are made, various meanings, and the affect of interviewer/interviewee struggle for understanding throughout course of interview.

Useful theoretical model is one that attempts to differentiate between

Textual – semantic emphasis (narrative versus free clause)

Ideational – coherent meaning (coherent themes and coherence relations)

Interpersonal – role relationship (varies with field of inquiry)

Critical research in field has long way to address problematic issues of

A single story or several related sub stories (demarcation of narrative versus non-narrative)

Analytic use of ‘function’ of narrative analysis "special kind of activity proper to anything, the mode of action by which it fulfills its purpose" (107)

Interpretation of narratives

Development of alternative models that begin to account for:

Reliability
Validity
Replication
Representativeness
Reactivity (key for Mishler)