Sociology 31, Section 1
Fall 1998
Professor Aldrich, Ms. Renzulli
Excellent term paper by Jimmie Pendergrass, from Fall 1996
WRITTEN ASSIGNMENT: TERM PAPER GUIDELINES
Choosing a Job to Study
Essential Rules:
1. You must
NOT study someone who is self-employed.2. You must
NOT study an immediate member of your family, e.g., father, mother, sister, brother.3. You
MUST choose someone to study who will let you observe them "in action," rather than only interviewing them.4. You must
NOT study a school teacher.5. You must
NOT study a family member in a family owned firm -- any worker you study must NOT6. You must
NOT study a UNC employee.7. The
BEST job to study is a blue collar or lower level white collar job, as that will let you see most of the principles we will talk about in class this semester.Team Papers
You may write a joint paper, under the following conditions:
1. Only two students per team.
2. The two of you must study different persons in the same job in different businesses. The "same" job means that the job title or job responsibilities are essentially the same. IF you are not sure whether the jobs are the same, please ask us.
Collecting Information
1. First contact: Make certain that the person whose job you want to observe KNOWS that you are doing a paper. Discuss what you will be allowed to observe, how you will do it, and if there are any restrictions on you.
2. Observing: Take notes as you observe. Remember that you will have to provide enough information so that a person who has no conception of the job will be able to visualize what it involves, just from reading your descr iption.
3. Interviewing: Do
NOT assume that you because you know the person whose job you are studying that you also understand the job. Ask as many qu estions as the person will tolerate! Check your assumptions by asking about them. Try to get the person to answer in his/her own words -- don't put words in his/her mouth. Save your course concepts for the paper. You can, of course, explain your interest in a particular part of the job by telling the person about a concept/principle you have learned in Sociology 31.Overview of the Paper's Content
The paper should cover the following:
1. Describe the job in terms of the dimensions of work we've discussed in this class (including, but not necessarily limited to: autonomy/control, meaning, satisfaction). Give the reader a feel for what it is like to work in the job you have studied.
2. Explain why the job is structured and experienced as it is: how much is a result of the particular person you studied (his/her skills, socialization, expectations, etc.), how much is a result of the employing organizat ion's characteristics (its size, personnel policies, technology, etc.), how much is a result of the nature of the industry, and so on. Describe the control system the job is embedded in, and how it functions.
3. What consequences does the structure of the job have for the person you studied (his/her family, career prospects, etc.) and for the employing organization (innovation, creativity, productivity, etc.).
General Suggestions
It's a good idea to use an outline. This will ensure that you address all the important issues, and it will guide their logical presentation as well. Use the Overview questions to subdivide the outline. The first outline you draw up will most likel y need to be changed as your paper is developed. One of the purposes of an outline is to keep your thoughts focused in the right direction, and as you proceed with the project it is natural for related ideas to emerge; simply incorporate the new material into logical places and make minor changes as needed.
Use sub-headings to divide your paper into sections, because it is easier for a reader to follow your argument with such guide posts.
Your paper will be evaluated in terms of form as well as content. In other words, how clearly you express yourself will be as important as your ideas themselves. One key to good writing is the arrangement of thoughts into well-organized paragraphs. A p aragraph is simply a group of sentences that completely explain one major idea. There is no "magic number" of sentences required, but if a paragraph is extremely long (more than 8-10 sentences), this may be an indication that your idea needs to be subdivided further.
Length
The paper should be about eight (8) pages long. If you need more space, please check with us first.
Style
Please observe the following carefully:
1. Double space, with normal margins.
2. Word process if possible; if not, type on a typewriter with a clean, new, dark ribbon.
3. Check carefully for misspelled words and mistakes in grammar -- these errors will lower the evaluation of your paper.
4. Use a separate title page with a descriptive title for your paper, your name, and the date. Start the first page of the text at the top -- no need to repeat the title
Finally
Keep in mind that a good paper is one that has undergone previous revisions. We encourage you to get feedback on your early drafts! Ask other students to critique them, give them to Linda Renzulli or Prof. Aldrich to review, or
visit the friendly folks at the Writing Center (Phillips Annex for appointments: 962-7710, or the Undergraduate Library for walk-in service: 962-4060). In general, try to start writing as soon as possible so that there is enough time for you to pro
perly revise your work.
Once again, we suggest you check out the excellent term paper by Jimmie Pendergrass, Fall 1996
Also, use the student term papers in the Coursepak as a guide.