Edited by Charles Kurzman
Available in paperback and clothbound from Oxford
University Press
and Amazon.com.
Selected original-language texts now available (see table of contents below).
Modernist Islam, 1840-1940: A Source-Book (Oxford University
Press, 2002) presents annotated translations of selections from
the work of 52 influential authors from the Modernist Islamic movement
of roughly 1840-1940. This movement, widely derided in the mid-20th century,
is undergoing renewed interest among scholars of Islamic history and liberal
Islamic thinkers. Twenty-two “section editors” with regional specializations
have selected the excerpts for translation, performed and/or supervised
the translations, and written short (250-word) introductions for each chapter, in conjunction with the project director.
Annotations are in keeping with the format of the project director’s predecessor
anthology, Liberal
Islam: A Source-Book (Oxford University Press, 1998).
The Modernist Islamic movement
was a major force in Africa, Asia, and Eastern Europe in the late 19th
and early 20th centuries, generating tremendous intellectual ferment by
attempting to reconcile Islamic faith and modern ideals. The movement pioneered
the formation or reformation of educational institutions; agitation for
political liberalization or decolonization; and the establishment of a
periodical press throughout the Islamic world. The Modernist Islamic movement
went into eclipse in the 1930s, supplanted by secular projects on one hand
(primarily nationalism and socialism) and by different religious projects
on the other (traditionalist and revivalist). In recent years, liberal
Islamic thinkers, once again attempting to reconcile Islamic and modern
values, have begun to resuscitate the reputation and accomplishments of
the Modernist movement. At the same time, Western scholars are beginning
to recognize, as they have not before, the extent of Modernist Islamic
activities and their importance in Islamic history.
The current project contributes
to the recovery of this important intellectual resource by translating
into English, annotating, and publishing in a single volume selections
from influential representatives of the Modernist Islamic movement, along
with an analytical introductory essay. This anthology brings the ideas
of Modernist Islam to wider audiences than they have previously reached,
particularly students of Islamic history and thought, who have relied previously
on the handful of existing English translations; and academicians and Islamic
thinkers, most of whom are familiar only with their region of specialty.
The anthology also serves as a counterexample to the popular image of a
permanent clash of civilizations between Islam and the West.
The anthology includes representatives
from: regions representing the breadth of the Islamic world; the several
phases of the Modernist Islamic movement (roughly 1840 to 1940); the variety
of issues that animated the Modernist Islamic movement and are once again
topics of lively debate in the Islamic world (educational reform, constitutionalism,
the relation between faith and science, and socio-cultural change); and
the variety of discursive forms that characterized the Modernist Islamic
movement (theological/scholarly, political, journalistic, fictional, and
theatrical).
Chapters
* represents a selection previously published in English.
† represents a selection translated for this project.
(Original) indicates that the original-language text is available in a PDF file.
I. Africa:
1. Rifa`a Rafi` al-Tahtawi (Egypt, 1801-1873), Takhlis al-ibriz
ila talkhis Bariz (The Extraction of Gold, or an
Overview of Paris, 1834)* and al-Murshid al-amin
(The Honest Guide, 1875)†
(Original of second selection)
2. Khayr al-Din (Tunisia, died 1889), Aqwam al-masalik (The
Surest Path, 1867)*
3. Muhammad `Abduh (Egypt, 1849-1905), “Ikhtilaf al-qawanin bi-ikhtilaf
ahwal al-umam” (Laws Should
Change in Accordance with the Conditions of Nations,
1881),† Risalat al-tauhid (Theology of Unity, 1897)*
(Original of first selection)
4. Qasim Amin (Egypt, 1863-1908), Tahrir al-mar'a (The Emancipation
of Woman, 1899)* and al-Mar’a al-jadida
(The New Woman, 1900)†
(Original of second selection)
5. Bahithat al-Badiya (Egypt, 1886-1918), “A Lecture in the Club of the Umma Party” (1909)*
6. Muhammad Rashid Rida (Syria-Egypt, 1865-1935), “al-Tajdid wa al-tajaddud,
wa al-mujaddidun”
(Renewal, Renewing, and Renewers, 1931-1932)† (Original)
7. Shaykh al-Amin bin `Ali al-Mazrui (Kenya, 1891-1947), Uwongozi
(Guidance, 1931)†
(Original)
8. Abdullah Abdurahman (South Africa, 1870-1940), “On Democracy” (1935)* (Original)
9. `Abd al-Hamid Ibn Badis (Algeria, 1889-1940), “Usul al-wilayat fi
al-islam” (The Principles of
Governing in Islam, 1938)†
(Original)
10. Muhammad Ahmad Mahjub (Sudan, 1908-1976), “al-Haraka al-fikriyya
fi al-sudan” (The
Intellectual Movement in the Sudan, 1941)† (Original)
II. Iran/Afghanistan:
11. Jamal al-Din al-Afghani (born in Iran, 1838-1897), “Lecture on
Teaching and Learning” (1882) and
“Answer to Renan” (1883)*
12. Mirza Malkum Khan (Iran, 1833-1908), Qanun (The Law, issue
#10, circa 1890)†
(Original)
13. Muhammad Husayn Na`ini (Iran, 1860-1936), Tanbih al-umma
(Admonition of the People, 1909)†
(Original)
14. Mahmud Tarzi (Afghanistan, 1865-1933), Chih bayad kard? (What
Is to Be Done?, 1914)† (Original)
III. Ottoman Empire:
15. `Abd al-Qadir al-Jaza’iri (Syria, circa 1807-1883), Dhikra
al-`aqil (Reminding the Intelligent, 1855)†
(Original)
16. Namik Kemal (Turkey, 1840-1888), “Wa shawirhum fi’l-`amr” (And
Seek Their Counsel in the Affair
[Qur’an, 3:159], 1868)†
(Original)
17. Ali Suavi (Turkey, 1838-1878), “Dimukrasi” (Democracy, 1870)†
(Original)
18. Semseddin Sâmi Frasheri (Albania-Turkey, 1850-1904), “Medeniyet-i
cedidenin ümem-i islâmiyeye nakli”
(Transferring the New Civilization to the Islamic
Peoples, 1883)† (Original)
19. `Abd al-Rahman al-Kawakibi (Syria, 1854-1902), Umm al-qura
(The Mother of Cities [Mecca], 1902)†
(Original)
20. Mahmud Shukri al-Alusi (Iraq, 1857-1924), Ghayat al-amani
(The Goal of Desires, 1903)†
(Original)
21. Abdullah Cevdet (Turkey, 1869-1932), Tarikh-i islamiyet
(History of Islamism, 1908)†
(Original)
22. Jamal al-Din al-Qasimi (Syria, 1866-1914), Kitab al-irshad al-khalq
(Book of People’s Guidance,
1911)† (Original)
23. Musa Kazim (Turkey, 1858-1920), “Islam'da usul-i mesveret ve hürriyet”
(The Principles of
Consultation and Freedom in Islam, 1908) and
“Kütüb-i kelamiyye’nin ihtiyajat-i asra göre
islah ve
te’lifi” (Reform and Review of Religious Writings
According to the Requirements of the Age, 1909)†
(Original)
24. Mansurizade Mehmet Sa`id (Turkey) “Taaddüd-i zevcat islamiyet'de
men` olabilir” (Polygamy Can Be
Prohibited in Islam, 1914)† (Original)
25. Ziya Gökalp (Turkey, 1875-1925), “Islamiyet ve asri medeniyet" (Islam and Modern Civilization)
(1917)*
26. Dzemaluddin Cauševic (Bosnia, 1870-1938), “Pismo i Odgovor” (Letter
and Answer, 1928)†
(Original)
27. `Abd al-Qadir al-Maghribi (Syria, 1867-1956), Muhammad wa’l-mar’a
(Muhammad and Woman,
1928)†
(Original)
28. Halide Edib Adivar (Turkey, 1882-1964), “Turkey Faces West” (1930)*
IV. Russian Empire:
29. Ismail Bey Gasprinskii (Crimea, 1851-1914), Mebadi-yi temeddun-e
Islamiyyan-i Rus (First Steps
toward Civilizing the Russian Muslims, 1901)*
30. Munawwar Qari (Turkistan-Uzbekistan, 1878-1931), “Islah ne demakdadur”
(What is Reform?,
1906).†
(Original)
31. Ahmed Aghayev (Azerbaijan, 1865-1939), “Islam i demokratiya” (Islam
and Democracy, 1909)†
(Original)
32. `Abdullah Bubi (Tatarstan, 1871-1922), Zaman-i ijtihad munqariz
mi, dägil mi? (Is the Time of
Ijtihad [Independent Reasoning] Over or Not?, 1909)†
(Original)
33. Rizaeddin Fakhreddin (Tatarstan, 1859-1936), Rusya Musulmanlarïnïng
ihtiyajlarï (The Needs of
the Muslims of Russia, 1908)†
(Original)
34. Abdal Rauf Fitrat (Bukhara, 1886-1938), Munazara (The Discussion,
1909)†
(Original)
35. Musa Jarullah Bigi (Tatarstan, 1875-1949), Khalq nazarïna
bir nichä mäs’älä (Some Questions
for the People’s Consideration, 1912)†
(Original)
36. Mahmud Khoja Behbudiy (Bukhara-Samarqand, 1874-1919), Pedarkush
(Patricide, 1913)*
37. Abdulhamid Sulayman Cholpan (Uzbekistan, 1893-1938), “Dokhtur Muhammadyor”
(Dr.
Muhammadyar, 1914)† (Original)
V. South Asia:
38. Khwaja Altaf Hussein Hali (North India, 1837-1914), “The Flow and
Ebb of Islam” (1879)*
39. Chiragh `Ali (North India, 1844-1895), The Proposed Political,
Legal, and Social Reforms (1883)*
(Original)
40. Sayyid Ahmad Khan (North India, 1817-1898), “Lecture on Islam”
(1884)*
41. Muhammad Iqbal (North India, 1877-1938), “Islam as a Moral and
Political Ideal” (1909)*
(Original)
42. Muhammad Abdul Khader Maulavi (Malabar-Kerala, 1873-1932), “Islam buddhiye acarikkunna
matumakunnu” (Islam Is a Religion that Respects
Reason, 1915)†
(Original)
43. Sayyid Ameer `Ali (Bengal, 1849-1928), The Spirit of Islam
(1922)* (Original)
44. Abu'l-Kalam Azad (Bengal, 1888-1958), Qaul-i faysal (The
Last Word, 1922)*
(Original)
45. Muhammad Akram Kham (Bengal-Pakistan, 1868-1968), “Bak tu di Qur’an”
(Back to the Qur'an, 1939)† (Original)
VI. Southeast/East Asia:
46. Al-Imam (The Leader) newspaper editors, “Uraian Melayu”
(An Exposition Concerning the Malays,
1908)†
(Original)
47. Ahmad Dachlan (Java 1868-1923), “Kesatuan Hidup Manusia” (The Unity
of Human Life, 1923)† (Original)
48. Ahmad Surkati (Sudan-Indonesia, 1872-1943), Al-Masa’il al-thalath
(The Three Questions,
1925)†
(Original)
49. Haji Agus Salim (Java, 1884-1954), Fadjar Asia (The Asian
Dawn, 1928-1929)†
(Original)
50. Ahmad Hassan (Singapore-Indonesia, 1887-1958), Soal-Djawab
(Question and Answer,
1931-1934† (Original)
51. Kyai Haji M. Hasyim Asy'ari (Java, 1871-1947), “Beberapa Nasehat”
(Some Advice, 1935)†
(Original)
52. Ya`qub Wang Jingzhai (China, 1879-1948), “Fazhan Yisilan Wenhua
Zhi Biyao" (Imperatives for the
Development of Islamic Culture, 1939)† (Original)
This page was last updated January 22, 2008.