Latest update: 10 March 2014

Mini Breeding Bird Surveys

Orange, Chatham, and Durham Counties

North Carolina

A Mini Breeding Bird Survey (MBBS) is a small-scale version of the full Breeding Bird Survey organized each year by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service throughout North America.

An MBBS focuses on one county.   Volunteers count birds seen or heard along randomly chosen routes on secondary roads.   The objective is to determine the distribution of breeding birds in the county and to assess any year-to-year changes in their numbers.

An annual MBBS began in Orange County (12 routes) in 1999, in Chatham County (14 routes) in 2000, and in Durham County (8 routes) in 2002.   The number of routes in each county varies with the size of the county.

Results from the first decade of MBBS (1999-2009)

results for each route (1999-2009)

some statistical analyses of trends for each species 1999-2009

A new decade for MBBS (2010 ...)

In 2010 we began to use eBird.org to store the results of our surveys.   Coordinated by the Cornell Laboratory of Ornithology and the National Audubon Society, eBird.org is now a widely used database for observations of birds worldwide.

By 2012 we had worked out kinks in this process . . .

and we covered all routes in Durham County . . .

and all but a few in Orange and Chatham Counties!

Last year we covered . . . all (of 8) routes in Durham . . . 11 (of 14) in Chatham . . .

and 9 (of 12) in Orange Counties.   We can do better!

For 2014, our goal is . . .

complete coverage in Durham and Orange . . .

and at least holding our own in Chatham!

An option for counting night birds (beginning in 2013) ... arrive at the starting point 15 minutes early (45 minutes before sunrise, approximately 5:15 at our time of year) and count all birds heard during those 15 minutes, and then start your first 3-minute count and continue the survey as usual.  

Enter the counts for the extra 15 minutes in the Comments box (see below for an example).

Reporting results by using eBird

Once you have run your route (review our procedures below) ...

  • add up the total number of each species for the entire 20 stops
  • log into ebird.org (how to log in)
  • after logging in, click the tab "Submit Observations" near the top

    On the page that appears ...

    1. choose your route in the drop-down menu "Select from My Locations" ...
    2. ... then click "Continue"
    On the next page ...

    1. enter the date you ran your route
    2. click the button for "Traveling"
    ... which expands the page so you can enter ...

    1. the start time (usually 5:30 -- don't forget to add AM) )
    2. the duration (within 10 minutes or so)
    3. the distance covered (always 10.0 miles)
    4. the number (of observers) in your party (normally 1 or 2)
    5. and "Comments" about your route
    Your comments should include ...
    1. names of observers (for instance, "observers=Firstname Lastname, Firstname Lastname")
    2. names of other participants such as driver or recorder (for instance, "others=Firstname Lastname")
    3. weather such as temperature, cloud cover, and wind in general terms (for instance, "weather=75F, partly cloudy, light wind, patches of fog early")
    4. the total number of vehicles during the 20 three-minute obervations (for instance, "vehicles=23", with no spaces), and
    5. any change in the habitat at any stop (for instance, "habitat@16R=B", with no spaces, meaning the new habitat code on the righthand side of the route at stop 16 is now B)
    6. any other notes or observations (for instance, "notes=Cooper's Hawk flew past after the count at stop 4, 3 Eastern Screech-Owls, 2 Barred Owls, 1 Great Horned Owl, 4 Whip-poor-wills, 2 Chuck-wills-widows during 15 minutes before the start")
    7. use semicolons to separate these types of information (also omit the quotes from the examples above)
    8. here's an example of a complete entry in this box ...
      observers=Haven Wiley, John Doe; others=Minna Wiley; weather=75F, partly cloudy, light wind, patches of fog early; vehicles=23; habitat@4L=S; notes=1 Barred Owl in 15 minutes before the start
    After entering these "Comments", click "Continue" to reach the final page ...

    ... where you can enter your totals in the appopriate boxes (scroll down as necessary).

    Once your totals are entered and you reach the bottom of the page ...

    1. click the button "Yes" for submitting a complete checklist
    2. and then click the big green button "Submit"

    On the next page, you are congratulated on a job well done ...

    "Your checklist has been submitted! Please review it carefully and make any necessary changes."

    Notice that you can change anything you have entered (if you made a mistake).

    Also notice the button near the top right corner "All Checklists".   Clicking this button takes you to a list of all checklists so far submitted!

    This list of checklists, allows you to "Edit" or "Delete" any of them (in case you think of a mistake later ... but please do not delete anybody else's list!).   You can also "Share" your checklist with another eBirder (or with your own eBird account).

    Click the tab "My eBird" near the top to take you back to the MBBS home page ... and finally "Sign Out" (although this step is not necessary if you close your web browser or the current tab).

    Why change the procedures for reporting data?

  • By using eBird, our data become available to the whole world for scientific analysis!

  • We no longer need someone to put our results on a website for us all to see -- somebody has a lot more time for birding (rather than web programming) as a result!

  • Even better, it is easier to start an MBBS in other counties or in other states or wherever!   A new MBBS requires somebody to select suitable routes (see the guidelines in our procedures), and to use Google Earth (or a GPS device) to obtain the coordinates of each starting location, and to spend a few hours with eBird to set up an account with the locations for the routes -- not really too much to do!

    What hasn't changed?

  • A successful MBBS still needs a county coordinator to make sure that participants are identified and that the routes are run and that the counts are entered in eBird.   However, that job has gotten easier -- because any one of us can use eBird to see a list of the routes for which results have been entered.   The coordinator can then focus on the participants whose routes are not in the list!

  • An overall coordinator is also necessary to check the data submitted.   This person's email is associated with the eBird account, so eBird will contact that person if it spots something irregular.   In addition, this person can check the "Notes" box for each count and edit for consistency and format.

    Comments on the procedures for submitting reports

  • Choosing locations from the drop-down menu -- One reason for shifting to eBird is that our data become available to anybody who would like to analyze them.   eBird follows the protocols for formatting data in the Avian Knowledge Network, so data can be downloaded for scientific study (it works although some programming is required!).   To allow our MBBS data to be identified for downloading, it is crucial that the names of the locations of our routes follow strict formats including spaces, commas, and capitalization.   Using the drop-down menu to select the location of an MBBS route solves this problem!

  • Vehicles and habitat codes -- A disadvantage of using eBird is that there is no easy way to enter the total number of vehicles on a route (those passing during the 20 three-minute observations) or any changes in habitat codes from year to year.   By adding this information in the box for notes, it will be possible to retrieve it when data are downloaded from the Avian Knowledge Network, provided we use the format suggested above (for instance, "vehcles=17" and "habitat@7L=M").

  • Sharing ebird counts -- Another disadvantage of eBird arises for birders who use eBird to manage their year, state, county, and life lists!   If you enter an MBBS route after logging into your own eBird account, the data will not appear in the appropriate MBBS account for us all to see easily (and there is the risk that the name of the location will not have the requisite format!).   If you then share this count with the appropriate ebird account, we can see it (and the name of the location can be corrected if necessary).   But ...

  • Sharing eBird counts (the bottom line) -- It is much better to enter the data in the appropriate MBBS account and then share it with your own account ... that way you can use the drop-down menu in the MBBS account to select the location with the correct format ... all of the species and numbers will also be tallied in your own account!

  • Locations and distances -- The locations of the routes are the starting places (please let me know if you spot a significant error!).   eBird suggests using the coordinates for the aproximate center of a traveling count, but for us the starting position is much more critical.   Although our routes only involve driving 9.5 miles from stop 1 to stop 20, we include all birds recorded within 0.25 miles of the first and last stops, so the total distance for an MBBS route is 10.0 miles.

     

    More information about . . .

    our procedures
    (revised May 2006, updated September 2009)

    including

    descriptions and maps of our routes

    a list of birds breeding in our area

    and

    printable forms for MBBS data

    If you have questions, please contact Patsy Bailey (Durham County) or Haven Wiley.

  •