Clonidine Versus
Ketamine to Prevent Tourniquet Pain During Intravenous Regional Anesthesia
With Lidocaine
Source: Gorgias et al. Reg Anes Pain Med 2001; 26(6): 512-7.
Reviewer: R. Prasad, MD
Summary:
-
15 patients, 3 groups (prospective, randomized, double-blinded). No premeds.
-
Double-cuff IVRA with 40ml lido 0.5% plus either:
-
saline
-
clonidine 1 mcg.kg
-
ketamine 0.1 mg/kg
-
After 10min, distal cuff up (250 mmHg), prox down. Start assessing tourniquet
pain (VAS q10min), timing tourniquet duration (blinded observer)
-
Groups had similar demographics, tourn durations (~95min)
-
Within-group comparison. Significant diff in tourniquet pain from baseline
-
lido 20min
-
clonidine 40min
-
ket 60min
-
Between-group comparison.
-
lido always highest VAS
-
clon and ket similar up to 40min. 50+ min, clon higher VAS
-
Tourniquet Tolerance TT = time from distal cuff inflation to first request
for tourn pain relief
| Group |
TT |
Total Fent |
| L |
25±6 min |
215±52 mcg |
| L-Clo |
45±8 |
137±40 |
| L-Ket |
71±7 |
70±25 |
-
No diff in sedation up to 30min after tourn release (non-signif trend for
more sedation in L, prob due to higher fent doses)
-
Psychomimetic effects
-
7 L-Ket pts (4 pleasant, 3 hallucinations, 3 paresthia, 2 dizzy, 1 nausea)
- "in general, ... weak and were not bothersome."
-
3 L pts (2 drowsy, 1 nausea)
Comments:
-
No power calculation done
-
Fairly high incidence of psych sx in ketamine group ... clonidine may be
better choice in older patients.
Home-Amb-Card-Crit-Neuro-OB-Orth-Pain-Ped-Reg-Tran-Vasc-Misc