2. catharsis (define then give 2 examples and explain its purpose
and/or effect)
A
catharsis is a purification or purgation bringing about spiritual renewal
or a release from tension; an elimination of a complex by acknowledging
it and allowing it expression. In Toni Morrison’s Beloved (1987),
both Paul D. and Beloved exists as catharisists for Sethe. Both Paul D.
and Beloved are representative of Sethe’s past: her days of slavery at
Sweet Home. Before Paul D. and Beloved arrive on the scene, Sethe has blocked
out her past, refusing to dwell on, or even acknowledge that period in
her life, only for it to come back to haunt her. Sethe doesn’t even tell
her daughter Denver about what happened at Sweet Home, not to any detailed
extent anyway. It is not until Paul D. and Beloved appear on the porch
of 124 that we learn what really happened to Sethe as a slave at Sweet
Home. Being a part of Sethe’s past, symbolically representing it, and physically
standing in front of her in the flesh and blood forces Sethe to come to
terms with her past and acknowledge what happened so that she can finally
let it go.
3. Brave Orchid tweaked her sister's
ears for hours, chanting her new address to her, telling her how much she
loved her, and how much her brother-in-law loved her. 'I won't let anything
happen to you. I won't let you travel again. You're home.'"
According
to Maxine Hong Kingston’s autobiography
The Woman Warrior (1975),
the Chinese used to tweak each other ears while chanting to each other.
They would "pull them back and forth " in order to call the person back
"in case [they] lost any of [their] self" (71). When Brave Orchid brings
her sister Moon Orchid to America, Moon Orchid goes insane as a result
of not being able to adjust to the new culture and endure the culture shock.
Brave Orchid trys to bring her sister back by tweaking her ears and calling
to her, chanting her new address in America. This quote illustrates the
lost of an identity of a self. In this case, Moon Orchid’s self is lost
in the web spun by two different cultures, just like Kingston’s own self
and identity is lost in her two cultures as well.
4. "'Ugh! but dat des do cuddle my blood.'"
In Charles
Chesnutt’s "Po’ Sandy" (1993) Uncle Julius, upon hearing the saw mill cutting
the timber, cries that it curdles his blood, jarring his " ‘memb’ance back
ter ole times, en ‘min’s [him] er po’ Sandy. Po’ Sandy was changed into
a tree by his conjure woman wife, Tenie, in order to keep from being moved
around so much from house to house with his services as a slave. Unfortunately,
Po’ Sandy was chopped down and sent to the saw mill to be cut up for lumber
to build a kitchen for the master’s wife; since Tenie was away she couldn’t
help him with her magic. This quote is significant because it displays
the dialect of Uncle Julius. This dialect serves to distinguish Uncle Juluis,
the help, from the masters he works for. All of the Chesnutt stories, "
Po’ Sandy," "The Goophered Grapevine," and "Hot-Foot Hannibal," use dialect
as a distinction between the classes. Chesnutt used this dialect as a means
of distinguishing between the classes of the characters in the novel to
make a point about the segregation classes in today’s society and the barriers
that separate them.
5. "The church bells, with various tones, but all in harmony, were calling out, and responding to one another- 'It is the Sabbath!-- The Sabbath!- Yea; the Sabbath!" - and over the whole cty, the bells scattered the blessed sounds. . . "
6. "After each bathing, Baby covered her
with a quilt and put another pan on in the kitchen. Tearing sheets, stitching
the gray cotton, she supervised the woman in the bonnet who tended the
baby and cried into her cooking. When Sethe’s legs were done, Baby
looked
at her feet and wiped them lightly. She cleaned between Sethe’s
legs
with two separate pans of hot water and then tied her stomach. . . with
sheets. Finally she attacked the unrecognizable feet."
In Toni
Morrison’s Beloved ( 1987), Sethe joins Baby Suggs and her family
at 124 after escaping from Sweet Home. Sethe, upon being raped by schoolteacher’s
nephew’s and then whipped for telling Mrs. Garner about it, flees from
Sweet Home and her days of slavery. Sethe, who has just ran barefoot through
the woods for days while pregnant, is in terrible shape when she arrives
at 124. In this passage, Sethe’s mother-in-law, Baby Suggs, is washing
her off and bandaging her wounds. This passage portrays the theme of dis-memberment
in the novel: Baby Suggs is literally washing away the remnants of Sweet
Home, removing them from Sethe’s life. With this Sethe is dis-membered
from Sweet Home. This theme of dis-memberment occurs also in Kingston’s
The Woman Warrior, when Kingston removes, or dis-members, herself
from the Chinese by acknowledging her American heritage with her voice
when she challenges both the little silent schoolgirl and her mother in
the last chapter of the autobiography.
7. "Beyond the housemaids room were the back stairs.
It was the nearest way down, and every step that Mrs. Clayburn took
was increasingly painful; but she decided to walk slowly back, the whole
length
of the passage, and go down by the front stairs. She did not know why she
did this; but she felt that at the moment she was past reasoning, and had
better obey her instinct."
In Edith
Wharton’s "All Souls’ (1937), the injured Mrs. Clayburn wakes to find herself
all alone in her own house with the power off and the phone lines down.
Mrs. Clayburn, despite her injured ankle and the doctor’s orders, decides
to check out the house. She cannot rely on reasoning because there is no
reasoning to be found as to why she is alone, or why she decides to check
the house, but she feels moved to, and since she has no reasoning she relies
on her instinct. This passage illustrates a reversal in class roles. Throughout
the story Mrs. Clayburn is portrayed as the high-class independent woman
living on her own, but here she is depicted as the helpless, lonely, old
woman. Instead, the servants are the ones with the knowledge and the power.
Mrs. Clayburn realizes that she needs her servants more than she thought
that she did. She is not as dependent as she would like to think she is.
This theme is also found in the story of "Luella Miller." Luella rules
those around her, treating them as her personal servants, forcing them
to do whatever she wants them to do. Just as with Mrs. Clayburn, when Luella
has no one to manipulate into taking care of her she loses her independence,
so much to the point that she literally grows weaker and weaker, until
one days she dies.
8. "But he was beautiful to see, and charming
as a comrade."
In Edith
Wharton’s "The Eyes" (1910), Culwin describes Alice Nowell’s cousin, Noyes,
as a young and untalented writer. While Culwin found Noyes to be far from
the predestined genius, he also found him to be "beautiful" and "charming"(39).
This quote suggests feelings of homo-sexuality between Culwin and his new-found
friend. Homo-sexuality is also suggested in James’s The Turn of the
Screw. This homo-sexual relationship has been argued to exist between
the young boy Miles and an older hired help, Peter Quint. Such themes as
this occur in stories as the result of the authors using their works to
identify and talk about taboos. Homo sexuality was a taboo, and through
their works the authors were able to talk about them freely without any
reprimands from society.
9. compare Luella Miller and Beloved
Luella
Miller and Beloved are similar in various small ways, but more specifically
in one major way. Each seems to have a uncanny power over those around
them. Luella is able to manipulate those around her to do whatever she
pleases, even when the town refuses to help her because of the mysterious
deaths, she is still able to beguile someone into doing her work for her.
Luella even has the power to make the school committee members turn their
heads the other way when Luella does not perform her job at the school.
Much in the same way, Beloved exerts a power over those around her. At
first, Denver is drawn in by Beloved’s power. Then when Denver begins to
realize that Beloved does not care for her and is just using her to get
to Sethe, Beloved moves on to the next character, Paul D. Beloved literally
moves Paul D. from place to place inside and outside of the house, not
to mention seducing him to touch her on the inside. And lastly, Beloved
exerts a power over Sethe who neglects her daughter Denver to be with Beloved.
Sethe even spends ALL of her money on sweets and dolls for Beloved. Luella
and Beloved are also similar in that they are outcasts from society. Luella’s
community refuses to have anything to do with her for fear of dying and
Beloved’s name is not even known to her community.
The differences
between Luella and Beloved are that Luella is an actual human and Beloved
is a ghost come back to avenge herself. Luella was also there from the
beginning of the story and Beloved doesn’t appear until later.
10. Emma Saxon
Emma
Saxon is a character in Edith Wharton’s "The Lady’s Maid’s Bell" (no publication
date found). Emma was Mrs., Brympton’s former maid, and is also the ghost
in this ghost story. Emma serves to protect Mrs. Brympton from Mr. Brympton.
While Mr. Brympton is away on business all the time, Mrs. Brympton has
formed a relationship with Mr. Ranford; an affair. Emma leads Hartley to
Mr.Ranford's house to let him know about Mr. Brympton. Emma also serves
to let Hartley know what is going on between Mrs. Brympton and Mr. Ranford.
Emma is significant because she, like a lot of the other ghost we have
read about, serve to either reveal a secret, for example Beloved reveals
the incident of Sethe killing her children, or to protect, like the ghost
dogs in Kerfol who protect their mistress from her husband.
11. Ethelred
Ethelred
is a character in the book that the narrator reads to Roderick Usher in
Edgar Allen Poe’s "The Fall of the House of Usher" (1839) in order to calm
him down. Poe’s use of Ethelred is called intertextuality: using or referring
to a separate text within a story. Ethelred and his adventures directly
correlate with the events in "The Fall of The House of Usher" : as the
narrator is reading the story of Ethelred, the hermit, and the dragon it’s
as if the story is coming to life. When the narrator reads of a sound,
he hears that sound in the house. Some have argued that Ethelred in Roderick
Usher and Madeline Usher is the dragon coming to break down the door to
avenge her wrongful death.
12. "For the love of all the evil that, in those
dreadful days, the pair put into them. And to ply them with evil still,
to keep up the work of demons, is what brings the others back."
This
passage appears in Henry James’s The Turn of the Screw (1995). The
governess is describing the two ghost figures of the novel: Peter Quint
and Miss Jessel who were both involved in scandals. The governess is commenting
on what it is that keeps them there in the human world with her and Miles
and Flora. This passage is significant because it expresses the main reason
why ghosts come back. If you "ply them with evil still" they will returns
to "keep up the work of demons" and finish their business.
13. framed narrative (define then give 2 examples
and their purpose and/or effect). Feel free to illustrate visually.
A framed
narrative is when a story is told through several different sources all
within the same narrative, for example James’s
Turn of the Screw is
an example of a framed narrative in which the story is told through the
narrator’s story of Douglas telling the story of his lady friend who wrote
the story of the governess who told the story of Peter Quint and Miss Jessel.
Another example is "Luella Miller" in which the narrator tells the story
of Lydia Anderson who tells the story of Luella Miller. The framed narrative
serves to characterize the narrator as unreliable because the story has
gone through so many different people. Even if the facts of the story doesn’t
change, the point of view certainly does and the relationships between
each individual narrators affects the story and how it is told, thereby
making the narrator unreliable.
14. "I shall be glad, for it will stop tormenting
me as it has done and always will otherwise. There hasn't been a day nor
a night since it happened that I haven't thought of it, and always I have
felt the shivers go down my back when I did."
In Mary
Wilkins Freeman’s "Lost Ghost" (1903) Mrs. Meserve begins to tell her friend
Mrs. Emmerson about her encounter with the little ghost girl who lived
in the house where she boarded when she was younger. Mrs. Meserve explains
that she cannot understand nor explain it and if Mrs. Emmerson can, she
will be happy so that it will not torment her so any more. This passage
is important because ghosts stay here in the human world to clear up some
business that they left unfinished. If Mrs. Meserve were to understand
the ghost and her encounter with it and what happened, it is likely that
she would not be haunted by the encounter anymore. People are scared of
what they don’t understand, and if Mrs. Meserve were to understand the
ghost, she would not be scared of it anymore.
15. "'Bad girl'. . . and sometimes that made me
gloat rather than cry. Isn't a bad girl almost a boy?"
In Maxine
Hong Kingston’s The Woman Warrior (1975), Kingston tells us that
her would scold her and call her a bad girl. Instead of making her feel
bad, Kingston would take pride in this name-calling because if you were
a bad girl then you were almost a boy. Being a boy was looked upon favorably
by the Chinese society. This quote is important because it expresses Kingston
search for self. She is faced with the conflict of girls being bad, and
instead of taking offense to the scolding, she takes pride in it, going
against the ideals of Chinese society.
16. "I was willing to humor the old man's fancy.
He had not told us a story for a long time."
In Charles
Chesnutt’s "Po’ Sandy" (1993) Julius explains to his masters that the reason
the horse won’t take the path that the driver has chosen is in the story
of Hot-Foot Hannibal. The narrator realizes that it had been a while since
Julius had entertained them with a new story, and decides that he will
humor him and let him tell it. This quote is significant because it makes
a strong statement about the class divisions in this time period. Even
though the relation between Julius and his master are good, the fact that
the narrator chooses to
humor Julius and his story shows
that the narrator does not see Julius as an equal. The word humor implies
that there is not truth or sense to the story that Julius is about to tell.
This theme of conflict between classes is seen in all of Charles Chesnutt’s
story in the interactions between the help and the masters.
17. "I did not murder my husband.'"
In Edith
Wharton’s "Kerfol" (1916), Anne Cornault claims that she did not kill her
husband in a trial where she is accused of murdering her husband. Anne
claims that the dogs that her husband killed over the years were what killed
her husband. This part of the short story is significant because it displays
the theme that one reason for ghosts is to protect it’s companions. Anne’s
dogs killed her husband because he was going to find out about her affair
and her plans to run away with another man. Similar to these dogs protecting
Anne, Emma Saxon in "The Lady’s Maid’s Bell" protects her mistress from
her husband who also was going to find about the affair between her and
another man.
18. identify three ghost children (characters) and compare the methods & implications of their deaths & returns
19. "Now, for the first time, it startled her
a little to find how little she knew of the material foundation on which
her happiness was built."
In Edith
Wharton’s "Afterward" (1909) Mary Boyne realizes for the first time that
her husband has been keeping her in the dark about the financial matters
of the house and the business when the lawyer explains to her that her
husband was mixed up in some "bad" business. This quote expresses the theme
of male dominance: when Mary inquired about the house or the business,
she was told that everything was taken care of and not to worry about anything.
She was left out of the financial affairs because she was a woman and would
not understand. Her husband tells her to not worry about it so she takes
his word that everything is okay. This theme of male dominance also appears
in "The Yellow Wallpaper" where Jane is separated from the rest of the
world because of her husband. Mary Boyne is separated from what is going
on in her own house because of her husband.
20. "Tell me your diamonds."
In Toni
Morrison’s Beloved (1987), Beloved inquires about Sethe’s diamond
earrings that she remembers gazing at when she was just a baby. This passage
exists as a means of remembering for both Sethe and Beloved. Sethe is forced
to think about her past when she tells Denver of her diamond earrings and
where they came from. Beloved remembers seeing the earrings shining as
her mother dangled them over her when she was little baby, still alive
and still a part of the family before her mother killed her. Through this
remembering Beloved in figuratively placing herself back into the family,
just as Kingston by remembering the story of her No Name Woman and the
ancient legend of Fa Mulan figuratively places herself in the Chinese culture.
21. "The horrible thing was that she still practiced
the same arts, all the childish wiles of a clumsy capering coquetry. I
felt her pull on my sleeve and it drew me in her wake like a steel cable"
In Edith
Wharton’s "Miss Mary Pask" (1925) the narrator realizes that Miss Mary
Pask is dead and that the woman his is standing in front of is in fact
a ghost. The narrator comments on the flirty mannerisms of Miss Mary Pask
as if she were still alive and a young woman. I think that this quote signifies
that the ghosts do not just die. Miss Mary Pask has her own desires and
need just like any other human being. Similar to this is the little girl
in the "The Lost Ghost" who needs and desires a mother. The died when she
was a child and remains a child in her ghost-life.
22. discuss the importance of one symbol in any
work
Edgar
Allen Poe uses the House of Usher to symbolize the decent line of the Usher
family. The house is old, dark, and melancholy just like the characters
in the short story are portrayed. The house also has a tremendous crack
down it’s walls to it’s foundation. This crack represents the breaking
up of the Usher family. Roderick and Madeline Usher are the last of the
Usher family decedents, and they are slowly but surely dying. The crack
can also represent the division of the mind and body of the Ushers: Roderick
represents the decay of the body and Madeline represents the decay of the
mind. Also, when both Roderick and Madeline are dead, the house falls with
the death, bringing an end to the Usher family.
23. "'But I wonder that the late Judge--
being so opulent, and with a reasonable prospect of transmitting his wealth
to descendents of his own -- should not have felt the propriety of embodying
so excellent a piece of domestic architecture in stone, rather than in
wood. Then, every generation of the family might have altered the interior,
to suit its own taste and convenience; while the exterior, through the
lapse of years, might be adding venerableness to its original beauty, and
thus giving that impression of permanence, which I consider essential to
the happiness of any one moment.'"
In Nathaniel
Hawthorne’s The House of Seven Gables (1990) Holgrave comments on
why the Judge, who was obsessed with his wealth and passing it on down
through the years to his descendants establishing a family name for himself,
would not have his house made of stone instead of wood. This way could
be changed according to the likes and dislikes of the generation to come,
but would still stay there forever to remain as a tribute to the Pyncheon
family name.
24. briefly compare the narrators and endings from "The Fall of the House of Usher" and "The Yellow Wallpaper"
25. identify, compare, and contrast two governess
In James’s
Turn of the Screw, the governess is made unreliable by Miles and
Flora. Miles and Flora continuously refuse to admit that they have seen
the ghosts Peter Quint and Miss Jessel. The governess in "The Lost Ghost"
is made reliable by Rosamond, because Rosamond is the one who see the ghosts
first. The governess of Turn of the Screw is also made unreliable
by her feelings towards her master, where the governess in "The Lost Ghost"
does not have a relationship with her master. The TOTS governess has just
been working with Miles and Flora for a short time, where the governess
in "The Lost Ghost" has been affiliated with Rosamond’s mom and her family
line for years. The governess in "The Lost Ghost" also seems to have genuine
concern for Rosamond, where the governess from TOTS is more concerned with
herself and whether she is sane or not than she is with the fact that Miles
and Flora are playing with ghosts. Also, the governess from The Turn
of the Screw changes her feelings towards the children throughout the
story where the governess in "The Lost Ghost" does not change her feelings
for Rosamond. She loves Rosamond as though she were her own child and loves
her in this way from the beginning to the end of the story. In TOTS, the
governess starts out liking the two children, and cannot imagine them being
bad, but then ends up despising the children believing that they are out
to get her.
ENGLISH 23E ESSAY
The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly:
Ghost and their Diverse Reasons for "Being"
An Anthology of Ghosts Stories
When looking
at why ghost are present in our world, there are numerous reasons ranging
anywhere from unfinished business, to protection, to revenge. Studying
Toni Morrison’s Beloved, Edith Wharton’s "Lady’s Maid’s Bell," Maxine
Hong Kingston’s The Woman Warrior, Mary Wilkins Freeman’s "The Lost
Ghost," Elizabeth Gaskell’s "The Old Nurse’s Story," and Edith Wharton’s
" All Souls’" provides a very diverse and varied array of reasons for ghost
to return after death from the underworld to join the human race. Some
of these reasons include revenge, protection, identification, unfinished
business, and jealousy.
Beginning
with Toni Morrison’s Beloved, ghosts return for revenge, or to avenge
something unjust that happened to them during their lives. In Beloved,
Beloved returns to avenge the wrongful injustice that her mother committed
against her when she killed her. In Sethe’s eyes the death was justified
by a mother’s unconditional love for her child, and the desire to so what
is best for her child by providing her with a better life. The only way
Sethe could provide Beloved with a better life was to take it. Beloved,
being as little as she was when the event occurred could not understand
this unconditional love and saw the death as a immoral crime committed
against her person as a human being. Beloved first begins to haunt 124
in the spirit form. Then as Paul D. drives her away without quenching her
desire for revenge, Beloved comes back in flesh and blood. Beloved wants
to understand why her mother could kill her and wants to take out her anger
on Sethe. Beloved has already managed to separate Sethe and Denver from
the rest of the community by haunting the house, leaving them with almost
no life. But as the story progress, Beloved begins to consume Sethe more
and more, killing her gently and slowly to avenge her own death.
In Edith
Wharton’s "The Lady Maid’s Bell" the ghost, Emma Saxon, is not there to
hurt or harm Mrs. Brympton, but instead to protect her. Emma makes herself
known to Hartley, the new made even though the others will not tell her
about Emma. Emma helps Hartley understand the situation with Mrs. Brympton,
Mr. Ranford, and Mr. Brympton. Emma also leads Hartley to Mr. Ranford’s
house to send a sign to him that Mr. Brympton is at the house.
In Maxine
Hong Kingston’s The Woman Warrior the ghost of No Name Woman and
Fa Mulan exists as role models for Kingston: both positive and negative.
These two ghosts also help to connect Kingston with her Chinese heritage,
thus helping her form her own identity. The story of the No Name Woman
haunts Kingston’s mind, and through the exorcising of this ghost Kingston
finds her own true self.
In Mary
Wilkins Freeman’s "The Lost Ghost" the little ghost child who is left alone,
abandoned and neglected by her mother returns to the boarding house in
search of her unfinished business: a mother. Once the little girl joins
with a mother figure she is gone forever and is never heard to haunt the
house again. The story of the little girl’s ghost exists only in Mrs. Meserve’s
head, serving to haunt her simply because she cannot understand. Once the
little girl has fulfilled her desire, and completed her unfinished business
by finding a mother to love and take care of her, she departs from the
human world to return to the ghost world.
In Elizabeth
Gaskell’s "The Old Nurse’s Story" the ghost of the little girl and her
mother return out of jealousy. The little girl is jealous of Rosamond because
she is accepted by the family and gets to stay in the house, where the
little girl was kicked out along with her mother simply for being born.
The mother is also jealous of the sister who still lives there. These two
ghost return out of jealousy and try to bring Rosamond out in to the snow
to die with them and share there misery.
In Edith
Wharton’s "All Souls’", the ghost returns for a traditional ritual. Each
year at the same time the ghosts return to the house. The ghost that Mrs.
Clayburn passes in the drive does not wish to harm Mrs. Clayburn, she is
only returning like she does every year for All Souls Eve.
There
is a long list of reasons that ghosts come back to haunt the people that
they do. Some of these reasons involve personal vendettas against others
and some reasons are merely to expose a truth or to finish some business
that was left undone in their life as a human. Not all ghosts want to harm
those that they haunt. Each of the ghost in Toni Morrison’s Beloved,
Edith Wharton’s "Lady’s Maid’s Bell," Maxine Hong Kingston’s The Woman
Warrior, Mary Wilkins Freeman’s "The Lost Ghost," Elizabeth Gaskell’s
"The Old Nurse’s Story," and Edith Wharton’s " All Souls’" exists for a
different reason.